A New Analysis on Project Lambda
patton
Teamed together with 5n4keyes, we have worked together these last few days in order to create a set of simple economic solutions to help our ailing economy. The basis for our economy's under performance is our gross over-production of manufacturing goods. Because of that our focus was to cut down that sector without jeopardizing the private sector.
This is the first article in a two part series. This article will examine the different points laid out by Project Lambda. After close review I see many parts that I think are goods ideas but, I also see some weak points. I do however, understand the courage it takes to make an economic plan and push it and I would like to thank Brian Boru for his contribution to Irish society. The second article will contain the ideas that Snake and I have put together. I have already messaged president Dubh about this plan and it is my truest hope that it would be a bi-partisan measure.
Disclaimer - I heard there was a new version of Lambda that fixes some of the old problems. However, I was not able to find a newer version so I had to base my analysis on the original plan.
If you want a reference on Lambda, Boru's original article can be found here
Here is the response to criticism of Lambda
Personal Point by Point Breakdown of Lambda - these points coincide with the original article
1. Accumulate Gold - I personally agree with accumulating gold for the state. However, the Ministry of Finance already buys excess gold off the market and sells IEP to make money. Since Boru does not elaborate on it any further Im not sure how he plans to get more gold then we are currently getting. Perhaps a good way to increase our finances would be to invest our funds in t'jelle bank or even get some of our more financial savvy citizens to create our own version of t'jelle with the profits going to the Irish state and the Bank Managers.
2. Identify Productive Companies - If you read the title it sounds good but if you read Boru's specifics some parts are unworkable. Boru says we would make workers work at only the productive companies and we would force them to switch over. Last time I checked you cant control citizens and I doubt this can work. However, I do like the idea of identifying Ireland's best companies and GM's and giving them the financial support to succeed abroad. Perhaps the Irish government if it helps out could get a share of the overseas sales ?
3. Setup of Extensive State Company System - First of all his third point contradicts his second point, if Im understanding this right. In this point he wants government run companies to supply the entire economy to end the " destructive competition " between companies. However, in point 2 he wants to funnel funds to some of the most profitable firms in Ireland ? Perhaps he is suggesting that the state companies will supply the domestic market and our private companies must only sell in foreign markets ? Personally Im fine with the current size of the state company program. I think it would be very hard to control the whole economy
4. Massive Tax Increases - In Boru's ideas taxes would be used to punish bad companies and redistribute income to the more productive companies. This sounds like it could be wide open to abuse since Im sure every TD would consider their company productive and would work to get it on the list. Plus if a MoF had any companies it would be very tempting to use it to eliminate competition. If used correctly though I have no doubt it work. I saw the same tactic used in eJapan awhile back. Also even though it might work Im still against the idea because I think Ireland can get more gold without burdensome taxes.
I tried to be as fair and unbiased as I could. Since Im a pretty charged guy Im sure that it leaked in some place 🙂
I will present Snake and my proposal either tomorrow or very soon. The rough proposal is complete but , I want to smooth out the edges. Thank you for your patience.
Comments
Indeed, there have been changes.
The focus for the state companies has been changed from filling the domestic market's needs to state weapons supply and export.
Furthermore, the taxes would only exist for a short period to kill off the dead wood, and all extra revenue from them would go towards subsidising the companies we've identified.
Great analysis. I'm looking forward to seeing your proposals!
http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/project-lambda-an-elaboration-1241680/1/20" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/proj[..]/1/20
So to clarify you mean the state company system would remain the same with the exception of exporting the state companies' products ?
What would be the process of identifying productive company and who would be in charge of selecting these ?
Nice stuff, patton (and Snake if you guys collaborated on this one)
♥
Look forward to the next articles!
I love the ideas you have here. Contact me if Ireland is interested in loans or a credit line 😉
Great analysis looking forward to your ideas
Alot of people voting but not alot commenting. Im not sure what that means.
"Alot of people voting but not alot commenting. Im not sure what that means. "
Org votes.
Im not an org
Tbh our economy is bad because of lana
And v2 uncertainty... Like every other country...
lana = the greatest goldsink ever conceived
There are plenty of good points in there Grainne. When I publish my joint plan with 5n4keyes we will be trying to address these problems. Our main focus here would be to limit the number of workers in manufacturing and so limit the current overproduction we see in that industry and the underproduction in construction in raw materials.
Personally Lana has never been a big deal with me because I do not use her. My spending habits are basically the same as they were in beta.
Im not sure though how many people are dumping goods in anticipation of V2 though. The admin has promised that no ones stocks are going to disappear or be less valuable.
@Grainne: I think I complained to you before about long comments like that. While it's certainly great to see you commenting on articles in Ireland once again, the one drawback is that people like me with short attention spans will get frustrated trying to read your comments! 🙂
patton,
people are dumping their goods because what deflation does. If you dont sell your goods, they will start losing value right away, so the only sensible thing to do is to dump them on the market and sell at all costs...which again drives down prices and increases deflation. Its a vicious circle....which is why deflation is nastier than inflation.
If you want a solution for Irelands problems, ask me 😛
So look the other way JG, Economics is not for the goldfish bowl 😉
And yeah patton, like I said, need to talk with committed Soldiers, 'cause theres loads of them about, and it is a clear driver... and whether they are native Irish or not, it's affecting everywhere.
Well Grainne Im not sure you can lay the whole economy at Lana's feet. Sure for someone with our high strength Lana siphons away our wealth but, what about all of the non-FMs out there ? They cant advance in rank without buying weapons, not in any sane amount of time. Not to mention every battle of every single real war everyone still uses weapons. Otherwise they would lose the battle.
lol, ok patton, forget it, clearly it isn't as big an issue for you here as the rest of the interlinked economies? Ask your weaps suppliers 😉
Good luck with your plans.