The Economist ~ Politics of change
Spite313
Dear friends,
For nearly a year now the UK has been bombarded with promises of change. Change of course brings the promise of a resettlement of the order, giving the chance for new players to rise to the top in an ossified political system. But the problem is that all of the people shouting loudest for change only want to change the players at the top, not the system itself, whatever they might say.
True change is impossible to bring from a top down perspective. Anyone claiming to run for CP to bring change is lying- it’s possible to improve a system, and do better at it, but genuine change never comes from a single person. To claim that is just egoism, and the kind of people who make that claim are also the kind of people history tends to forget. True change comes from the bottom up, a popular/cultural change in the society or group which filters upward, rotting the foundations from beneath any hierarchy.
Now this might sound very revolutionary, but it’s not except in the most literal sense. There is a revolution going on right now in the UK, but it’s not the kind of violent overthrow of the old order most people associate with the word. Instead it’s a painless revolution, a kind of awakening of responsibility and duty amongst the general population which is quietly making government irrelevant.
Most Presidents make big promises when they run for election, this month Invalidation has done the opposite. I am going to be accused of bias, but I have to say this is the best, most honest manifesto I have read from any candidate in the past two years. It calmly and quietly lays down the facts of our current situation, asks for people to trust him, and promises absolutely nothing except to try and get people to do the government’s job themselves.
The cultural shift that is currently attacking the foundations of the UK is a shift towards self-reliance, self-determination and small government, and it is perfect. It is clear that the new world is no longer a world where socialist or cooperative models of society are even viable, never mind desirable. Whereas once it was possible for the government to levy huge 25% taxes and employ a quarter of the population, now it simply isn’t. Without organisations, without contracts, with the kind of income governments receive - it isn’t possible to run that kind of society, and we’ve known it for years now.
But the big revolution that came with the disbanding of the UK Army and the end of UK national companies never reached the political sphere. We had a military and economic privatisation, but political power remained concentrated in the hands of professional politicians. Why? Because people wanted it to be that way. It’s often easier to allow others to make the decisions and take responsibility, but it was a sad case of head buried in the sand. The game has changed, and the UK has took all this time to acknowledge it.
Now we live in the time of the citizen-soldier, the merchant prince and the political activist. If you want something done, the person you need to harass is yourself. If you need supplies, work out how to get them, don’t expect someone else to do it. If you want to raise support for a war, or quest for bonuses- get out there and do it. That is the time we live in. We have a private NHS, a privately written new player guide, private MUs, and the government has been reduced to chief representative of the UK community abroad, and intermittent signer of MPPs. That’s a good thing.
People often ask me why I don’t marry my real world economic, political and military beliefs to eRepublik. The answer to that seems obvious to me, but I should explain- it’s because this isn’t real life. It is a game, and like all games a full understanding of the rules is the way to win. I’m sure blasting your way across the battlefield in a FPS game you don’t pause to wonder whether Herr Von Kampf sniping at you from the bushes has a family, and similarly when I write that we should disband government in eRepublik I don’t wonder whether it would be sad if my grandmother died because there was no NHS in the real world. It’s not the same- don’t extend your RL beliefs and prejudices into a game. Role play is fine, so long as it doesn’t make you lose.
As a final addendum to this, I’ll be voting Invalidation/Alice not because he agrees with me but because regardless of whether he agrees with me or not I will still be free to do as I like. He understands the culture the UK has stepped into, and although he might not be the first to do so, he’s the first to put it so clearly in a manifesto. From now on, if something isn’t done, or needs doing better, the only person you can blame is yourself.
Iain
Comments
first
laughed out loudly, in excelso ridente
Even , I haven't wasted my time reading it...
You can read?
The revolution will be brought to you by the same people who have run things for years.
The revolution is that they will do even less for the country because they can't be bothered with even the illusion of doing things anymore and have already stolen/lost all of the national companies.
After attacking people who made their own armies and newbie schemes - they now want us to make our own armies and newbie schemes.
Of course when we tried a real revolution last year, it was Iain at the head of trolling it into submission by using his and his friends positions in alliance HQ.
I am comfused.
No, see this is why you're not capable of understanding (also don't understand how to comment apparently). The revolution won't be brought by Alice or me or any of the people who have been working in the government for years. It's brought by the whole community, and the revolution is that power is shifting from meaningless titles to people, who actually have the power to do things.
All you know how to do Goku is try to make yourself king of the hill. Years of trying and failing and you still don't realise your aggressive and antisocial behaviour doesn't appeal to people, and constantly trying to blacken other people's name just makes you look like you hold a grudge.
Please read my article again, because you either didn't understand it or didn't do me the basic courtesy of reading it.
So you only support change when its your guys doing it. This is what the article criticised, perhaps you should read it again and reduce the 'comfusion'
Since my PP terms where I could nominate a CP candidiate outnumber my CP runs 10:1 or more, that probally was never my aim? I even PTOed a country or two and didn't try to run it. I don't know what other hills there are to be king of.
When I post an article you and friends are right there calling me out on things you feel are not correct. So I am doing nothing that yourself or your friends have never done in name blackening.
The only difference is that there are more of your side because I won't suck up to anyone for friends, but that doesn't make you right.
I support change no matter who does it, I hope that half of this stuff is true.
But the other half reads like an excuse for you and your friends to take government jobs for status and do nothing.
I am confused as to where I have called anyone out. I have merely explained that trying to give yourself control of a country is not a revolution, a revolution is a societal shift. If anything, your main contribution toward's the UK's "revolution" has been showing them the bleak alternative.
I've not held any position in the UK government for years other than helping out with the odd article and some government org listing now and then.
If you really think I have more "friends" because I suck up to people you are a poor judge of character. I don't suck up to people, I always tell the truth and put things as clearly as I can, and it's definitely not stuff a lot of people want to hear. What you do is try to mislead people by painting yourself half victim half leader of the downtrodden, when you are neither.
What is your argument here, just a personal attack to deflect attention from yourself?
I wasn't very clear on my point. Obviously you and Invalidation have gotten together to cook up a CP run and you are both posting positive sounding things.
However these positive things are often the total opposite of your past actions, with hostile campaigns run against these independant MUs and NHS style schemes by yourself or your allies.
This needs to be pointed out and you both need to explain your change of mind, as well as why the Government doing even less is a reasonable thing and not just a route to an easy life for you both.
If you read my past articles and forum posts you'll find I've argued strongly for private MUs and a privately funded NHS since the beginning. In fact, it was a TUP government which disbanded the UK army and a TUP government which privatised the NHS. Not that I am always in favour of everything a TUP CP does, but you can hardly pin me for inconsistency on those- I actually designed the current NHS system for Christ's sake.
If you read back I didn't even criticise party MUs though many people did. I supported TUP Family and though obviously we are rivals with British Army I didn't once say it didn't have a right to exist. The only criticism I had, however fleeting, was when the commander and his fellow leaders were tanking against the UK for Ireland.
Now Alice only told me he was planning to run yesterday and to be honest I didn't think he ever would. But his manifesto is very strong, very honest and doesn't pull any punches. If only you could say the same!
I am frankly sick of your constant negativity and unhelpfulness Goku. When you quit last time I hoped we'd seen the back of you, and I don't think that about many players. The victim complex and the constant whining and attempting to find something wrong with your opponents even when they're saying sensible things is just partisan for the sake of it, and it's hardly surprising that you have alienated the vast majority of the UK through it.
Personal attack again. To your relevant point, sure I guess you don't support everything your friends do... but you never stepped in and told them publically that attacking, say the New Era NHS scheme, is wrong.
Invaidation just said in his manifesto that the groups running MUs and NHS schemes are dependant on him liking them, if he doesn't he will try and destroy them just like he did with the New Era MU and NHS schemes.
çok biliyon
Traitor of TWO
?
This old dinosaur might just be on to something. OFF WITH KRAVENN'S HEAD!!
Should of voted Wayne...
[removed]
I think the 'evil' sod has bleedin' got it!
Lovely article
Invalidation4CP!
Great article though I disagree that real change can only occur from the bottom up. The sonderweg argument regarding Germany essentially states that unlike other European nations change in Germany occurred from the top down.
Enjoyed reading it a lot,
especially the part about "why I don’t marry my real world economic, political and military beliefs to eRepublik" [...] "It is a game, and like all games a full understanding of the rules is the way to win." [...] "It’s not the same- don’t extend your RL beliefs and prejudices into a game. Role play is fine, so long as it doesn’t make you lose."
Maybe there was more progress in this game if this was a more common kind of thinking.
Invalidation4CP!
Support for one of the biggest trolls in UK, a bully.
No thanks
Too right, that's why nobody wants you to run!
The Real Spamicans and the 'EVIL' Keers on the same side? Whatever next!?
Horice 😒
Time you gave up this game Keers so boring.
Shouldn't you be tanking against the UK or something?
Get a girlfriend or are you allergic to vaginas ?
>Implying I haven't
The problem you have, which is shared by many, is that you assume it's impossible to be good at one thing without being bad at everything else. I tend to find that people who are intelligent and committed enough to do well in one thing often find that success replicated in other aspects of their lives.
It might seem unfair to you that I'm better at you at this game and at real life as well, but then life really isn't fair is it? If you show the same commitment and intelligence you do in your real world relationships as you do here, then you are going to face problems.
Buying friends, making childish insults against opponents, running away when things get hot- these aren't attractive traits. You might want to talk about that to your friends and family.
Dude you are serious weird , saying your better at me at this game is just weird , you are fooking useless get that into your head, you are useless , how long have you been playing the game ? where is the uk national unit you greedy little person , enjoying all your mines are you , dude you suck at this game big time , as look at the uk rank 30 no nothing , asking people to help new players , you sux , that proves it , you have done NOTHING for the uk otherwise it wouldn't be in such a mess shame on you thinking you are billy big balls , all you do is click a button and produce wrm , are you good cos you can bully people ? you are control freak of a free web based game , SAD
The reason the eUK is so shite is not the fault of one man... seems you haven't changed your spots Dapper.
Wayne for the last week ,Keers has trolled any New Era , Jedi Article his a serious pr1ck , so fooked him and fook TUP
Be the better man and just ignore it...
You mean the articles where you boasted about how much damage you did for the UK?
After doing countless billions against us? How is it trolling to call you traitors when you are?
You disagreed with a few people in government so you took some of the strongest tanks in New Era and went to Ireland, where you tanked billions against the UK in key battles, and ruined our good name in front of our allies.
Pointing that out isn't trolling, it's highlighting hypocrisy. If Dapper was going to be the bigger man he'd admit he's a traitor to everyone in the UK.
*nods head*
After 6 years the TUP Iain Keers and his pals have done nothing for the UK. they have bulit no national unit they have nothing to show for 6 years of power and control
Where has all the money gone ? wasted !
Where is a national unit : Don't have one ?
Where do the taxes go ? Good question
What rank are the UK ? 30 that 2 less than last year
One word that sums up your time in this game is pathetic (miserably inadequate)
They don't even have a system to supply food and help people they ask from citizen help, it is just a joke , the army is a joke, they have no clue, these mass bully and troll and like to keep it all inside the click , if you speak out they troll and smear you , these are true words from a honest person , they sit on their little click in IRC and think they control the real world most of these people need to get a life
You are your pals are clueless , greedy and just out for yourself !
Each month they tell you who to vote from to keep the click going , and give no one else a chance !
Think of the future of the eUK for once instead of being like a real life politician.
lol
Still doesn't understand anything. Forever noob
You don't that is why the country is a joke to everyone else , you are a noob mate , greedy little man, you can't answer as you know I'm RIGHT ! have to insult as you are weak have have no answer, win for me !
I don't argue against you because anyone reading what you just wrote is going to think negatively of you anyway so I needn't waste my time
dapper, if i were lain and known where u live in rl, u might have a very serious depression now.
You are a greedy man Keers who does nothing to help the country really , just out for number 1 ,
Actually the UK's ranking is 24th, as opposed to being 30th in population numbers. Being 6 places above our pop. isn't too bad in my opinion.
I was stunned to find I agree with the ''Evil One''.
My name is Iain Keers , I think I'm wonderful at this game , holy sh1t what a man I am, when people speak the truth I have to insult them , when people point out my failings I call them a noob as I have nothing else to argue with them
DUDE YOU ARE USELESS FOR THIS COUNTRY
6 YEARS AND THE COUNTRY HAS NOTHING DUE TO YOU
you are a joke true story
You are quite an angry man.
http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/the-economist-dastardly-banking-launch-2337859/1/20
This story proves Iain thinking , the rich get the rich , you only care about you and your rich mates in the game
I hope you don't have your dirty hands on the orgs again more , we got them off you last time and you shouldnt be in charge of any orgs
|Power to the people
Maybe you can ask Ireland to loan some orgs in exchange for your tanking! Hail CoT. . Amirite traitor face?