Home is where the heart is...
Laurana Psion
As you may be aware, the Japanese Diet (or Congress if you prefer) has long been debating the issue of funding the Japanese Imperial Army (JIA). What was once a proposal to provide funding to our mobile forces, the Japanese Imperial Expeditionaries (JIE), has now been expanded to cover our domestically bound forces, the Japanese Imperial Guard (JIG), thus providing funding for the JIA in its entirety. I for one can tell you that there were many sighs of relief and outright celebration in the main JIA Barracks, when it was announced that the Diet had, in a preliminary vote, unanimously approved of the new scheme of funding. With this new legislation in place, we can at last truly claim to have an official standing army.
As it stands, 25 Gold has been allocated to the JIA for a trial period of one month (with the added intention of building up an additional reserve fund for use in emergencies). At the end of this time of review, the Diet intends to gauge the adequacy of the current level of funding before determining the JIA’s future budget. Although this sum of money has been long awaited and is now most happily received by our armed forces, there are still many who are dissatisfied with these hard-won results. The very sum of 25 Gold has been labelled as “pathetic” when contrasted to the fact that even a young entrepreneur owning only a raw materials company is capable of raising a similar amount on his own.
Indeed, one can’t help but wonder if this funding is simply too little too late. Before the approval of funding, there had already been one incident in which a member of the JIA had resigned. The reasons that were cited in his letter of resignation were linked very closely to the problematic and lengthy deliberations congress has had over the creation of an appropriate military budget. The views expressed indicated that paying one’s own expenses while training and fighting as part of the national army was “foolish”. By leaving the army, he would have more control over how, where and when to do his military training; whilst in the army, he gained no tangible benefits and yet was bound by the regulations of the JIA.
One would think that with the Diet’s approval of the first (albeit provisional) military budget, the growing discontent within the army would have been finally stemmed. This however was not to be so. Just two days following this milestone in Japan’s history, four more members of the JIA tendered their resignation. All of whom cited similar reasons to those from the first official resignation. However, upon further prodding and investigation there was yet another layer behind these apparent reasons.
It would seem that a shared sentiment is a lack of faith in Japan’s administration and course in eRepublik history.
“I’m a little disappointed in the Japanese community”
“There’s nothing new and there never will be, sad to say but its true”
“You can have a month’s long political debate without it leading to anything at all”
“I just didn't feel myself at home in a country that doesn't want to develop... I'm sorry if I gave the picture that in my opinion no one cares; there are some but too few who care”
Given these underlying reasons, it may not be too surprising that these individuals have also chosen to renounce their Japanese citizenship in addition to their military status; an act that I must say is far more disheartening to me than that of resigning from the JIA alone.
Two public faces of the JIA had the following to say in response to these recent events. Congressman Reiji Mitsurugi, who has previously done much to highlight the importance of funding, was brief, observing that “the Diet's hesitation to fund the army is leading to a terrible epidemic of desertion that is eroding our national security”. On the other hand Secretary of Defence Geno Garon had a far sharper point to make.
“Tell me if you see any pattern or feature that the people who quit share. They are ALL from the Council of Zen, a group of Finnish politicians who imposed [upon themselves] a self-exile from Finland to try and turn Japan into their own political haven... They never became Japanese, they never tried to be... They are not what I call citizens; they are what I call a PTO group.”
In response to the these statements, I must say that they are essentially true. Although it is true that they have tendered their resignations according to JIA regulations, one cannot help but feel that what they have done is nothing more than a legalised desertion; especially when they choose to also renounce their citizenship at the same time. It has been observed that the 25 Gold is a humble beginning but a beginning nonetheless and that a true citizen would stand by the country through thick and thin.
It is said that “home is where the heart is”, and quite obviously, the hearts of those who have resigned (both rank and abode) do not belong here in Japan, as they themselves were aware.
“I've also spent a fair amount of time [training] abroad and haven't considered myself as a citizen of eJapan for some time already”
“I just didn't feel myself at home”
"I believe I won't return to Japan. I mean, why would I? Don't get me wrong, there are some very cool persons there (Origineel, Inferno, Sophie and Minamoto to mention few) but I believe "my place" is elsewhere."
But then, where do their hearts lie? Were they at heart citizens of another country all this time while they were here? One person gave a solemn though mournfully eloquent reply:
“I'm sorry for my actions but this decision had to be taken since I found myself in a dead end. My future is at the moment a complete mystery for me, I really cannot say anything [as to] what I'm going to or not going to do. I don't know. I'll probably stay training in Hungary although I'm not going to read their media or find their forum. I haven't planned [all] this... I might wander around the eWorld a bit after reaching FM.”.
Another gave a short but simple and succinct reply (perhaps an artefact of his military career): “I didn't expect Japan to be 'another Finland' but still I was a bit surprised about the way things were done there. No hard feelings though, it was quite an experience overall”.
They may not have felt truly at home here, but neither did they feel at home elsewhere. It would be wrong to go so far as to accuse them of having been here under false pretences when Japan may have been more of a home to them than anywhere else. If they now feel they do not belong and wish to leave, then by all means let them. I say this without any hint of malice and hope to believe that most, if not all of us, are of the same feeling; despite her small size, Japan does not seek to retain people here against their will, and neither needs nor benefits from having such reluctant citizens being present.
All the same, we should bear them no ill will if they have shown none towards us. There is no use crying over spilt milk. Let us not dwell on these recent actions of theirs no matter how much we disapprove of them and instead remember what they have done for us. Indeed, one of these men who will be leaving us has played a crucial role in helping to draft the very charter and regulations that validates and governs the JIA. If not for this effort, the JIA would not be the entity it is today.
In resigning, they have wished those of us here farewell and good luck and I do the same to them.
[As a mark of respect and to maintain their anonymity, I have chosen out of my own free will not to disclose who specifically said what even though they have by and large given me permission to directly quote them.]
Home is where the heart is... but is Japan where our hearts are? Many current residents did not choose to start out in Japan and instead found themselves on these fair isles in search of greener pastures. Perhaps the true crux of the problems outlined above lies not within the bureaucracy of the Diet or even in the concerns of governmental funding, but in the fact that people do not come here for the right reasons. As seen above, loyalty and dedication may be enticed or lured by the prospect of financial or otherwise material gain, but such rare and true service ultimately cannot be bought and retained.
Steadfast devotion can only be brought about by a deep bond to the local community. It is a strongly united and friendly community that we of Japan should be proud of, and it is this that should be advertised. It is neither the military nor the politicians that make a country; and certainly not the arms or funds available. What makes a country are the generous hearts and the noble minds of it's people, and it is ultimately on the active presence of this very human element that this nation will stand or fall.
I understand that some of us may have ties to more than one country for whatever reason and that is fine by me. Those of us who are not native to Japan will no doubt always remember the time spent in their first place of abode, the nation where they would have first grown accustomed to e-life and made personal connections with the local community. However, after being in Japan for some time, some part of ourselves should at least feel that we belong here and if this isn’t so, then I hate to say it, but both ourselves and Japan are better off in the long run without our presence here.
Where do our hearts lie?
Where does yours?
_______________
Hoping that this wall o' text has not rendered you blind,
Laurana "Psi"
10/07/2009
_______________
Sponsored by:
The Zetsubō Shimbun; "Omnia Mutantur Nihil Interit".
Like what you see? Why not subscribe?
_______________
Comments
Nice article - summarized the situation well.
Great article, cya Japan. Where do i go now? I don't want to go in Finland, cause it's sucks. I guess i will just stay in Hungry and fight... :/
I do quite frankly also understand the issue Minister of Defense Geno Garon was feeling however. Were they here for the betterment of the Nation, or where they here to take personal benefit from the Nation. It is truly difficult to say. One may call this non sense, and other may feel this to be more important reason than others may feel. However, when those same politicians who are making proposals and demand for more money to JIA is taking the benefit of the fruit of their successful passing of the legislation, it is truly difficult to tell whether those politicians and congressmen who is vocal in the congress, and take a active role in army and benefit from the army are here for the general betterment of the nation as a whole, or for their own personal benefit from the army. it is tough question. Since the same people proposing to raise the funding are those who are in the army and getting free weapons to train themselves. It is difficult situation, I would say, since from one point of view the whole situation could look 180 degrees different than if you looked at it from another point of view.
I'm Reiji Mitsurugi, Press Secretary for the Japanese Imperial Army, and I approve this message.
And, for the record, my heart is here, in Japan.
Thank you very much, dear Psi, for producing this extremely detailed, beautifully organized, and downright compelling article. I will direct my colleagues in the Diet to come here and see if maybe their stubbornness will turn to the same zeal for the army that I share.
I, for one, salute you!
@Akki
Now that the army has lost its "big greedy people" and is left with mostly the "little people" maybe you could consider providing it a budget that's not best described as ridiculous.
Although it would already be a remarkable improvement if the congress could extend the debate to include more than a handfull of congress(wo)men. Also it might consider moving from chit-chat to decision making. Otherwise you could aswell not have a congress or congress section in the forums.
Also do you really think it impossible that one could seek a personal benefit (which I consider becoming happier to be) through bettering the nation and thus improving everyones eLife's quality? They aren't necessarily separate; one can be achieved through another.
The best of luck for all of eJapan, sadly you're going to need it unless you take your destiny in your own hands intead of flying blind.
I'm glad the article has been well received so far. Constructive criticisms are of course welcome!
Miyamoto: Thanks. I didn't expect it to be this long but hopefully, most people won't tl;dr it.
Akki: Yes, I am fully aware also. As such, I have attempted to portray the situation as neutrally as I humanly can. Hopefully, people will be able to see both sides of the event and make the final decision on their own.
Reiji: Cheers, hope I didn't steal the show from you seeing how you ARE the official spokesman.
Meh, I like some of the CoZ. They can be a pain for myself, but some of them have a very good heart. I guess it is inevitable that they are not tied down here, they really have no reason to stay in a country that means little to them, right? This is a game for fun. They came here for fun, found nothing, and left. Its understandable.
To be honest, I don't like the rush with the military funding. Japan has never had a serious working Military before, so we should really be moving into it slow. 25G was indeed a nice amount of budget for the first time around. I have been watching the treasury and determining how much Gold and JPY we get in taxes, and I am sure in some time we can slowly raise it. I don't see why there is a huge rush to do it, we have no threat upon us. Should we need to defend ourselves we can do what we have always done, ask PEACE to support us. We want to see trial runs with less money before we give you something more substantial.
Nice article. I really enjoyed to read it.
Akki 😃 you are amazing, you just said same thing 3-4 times in your comment...
But I can answer to that (not 3-4 times, hopefully 😁. We were there for making a better nation, not for making personal benefit from the nation (..like some kind of businessman who owns ~50% of some nations companies and speaks loudly for low taxes... No.). The truth is that the military needs funding and it still needs funding when "we" are not there. It is true communism when you have to BUY your weapons for training and fighting.
And back to article: I love you Geno. 🙂 You could at least thank us that we made your little (actually, 5 members is _tiny_) party successful.
And yes, it wasn't only this army issue that made me leave, it was whole system and the "No taxes, with donations We Can!" -mentality. I personally hoped that the army would bring about changes to this system - the army needs real money and the current system is not bringing it in.
And the last(?) issue: Nearly anything were ever finished. There could be congress debate about a proposition and it could even pass through, but after that? Nothing. There is something wrong in system if you can debate, vote but will never see the finished product.
For me leaving is the only viable option. I don't want to read huge walls of text where writer says nothing. I can't stand debates going on and on and on... I can't take it. So the only thing left for me to do is to stop.
Leave.
For ever?
"However, when those same politicians who are making proposals and demand for more money to JIA is taking the benefit of the fruit of their successful passing of the legislation, it is truly difficult to tell whether those politicians and congressmen who is vocal in the congress, and take a active role in army and benefit from the army are here for the general betterment of the nation as a whole, or for their own personal benefit"
Same could be thought of General Managers of several big companies who are voting on governmental actions of taxes and monetary market control.
---
Everything has sides, nothing is just black and white.
Council of Zen, as the name hints, was a peaceful group of politicians. I can only talk about myself, but at least I always had the intention to have a positive influence to eJapan, to make this counrty prosper and shine. Too bad the whole group was instantly judged as PTO'ers, and not even given a fair chance.
I'm totally ignoring GenoGaron's words here as they are words of a cynical and populist man. You were happy back when CoZ joined OP and lifted you to top 5. 😉
I indeed was a part of this group, and I'm not an "original" eJapanese, but I still haven't given up my hopes that eJapan could be where my heart is.
Good article and nicely written, but this tells only a part of the truth.
I don't really like reprimanding people too much so I'd just like to request that EVERYONE please refrain from stirring up hostilities over past matters. As I tried to get across in the article, we should let sleeping dogs lie and move on forwards (to sorta paraphrase kokawa). If you insist on dredging up/making a point on past matters that do not have a direct relevance to this article, feel free to open up a thread on a forum or post another article.
Orai: I'm glad someone is aware that this is not utter serious business (despite some believe). I also am aware that our military is both young and modest and as such, I agree with taking it slow. Regarding the 25 Gold/budgeting/treasury concerns, I cannot comment seeing how I have not truly paid enough attention or done any real research into it.
Mursu: "tells only a part of the truth"
Perhaps but I was not present during these past events and as such, I do not believe it my place to focus more on those incidents.
I have only been a citizen of Japan for about 2 months now. I am currently enlisted with the JIG. It is unfortunate that people would rather give up and quit instead of doing something to help resolve the situation. The lack of funding to the JIA was the main reason I ran for congress. Sure, those in the JIA would also befefit from the JIA being funded, but that's how this whole game works. Actually, if you want to get technical about it, the whole country of Japan befits from our military being funded. Even if people are doing these things for selfish reasons, it is better than doing nothing at all. Everything that is done is done for selfish reasons, even if done out of the kindness of our hearts. If we are to help someone in need, do we not want that "thank you" or just the good feeling of helping someone?
Like I said, doing something for selfish reasons (if it helps out eJapan also) is better than doing nothing at all.
Minamoto and myself decided we were sick of the military not getting funding. Did we quit? Hell no. I love Japan and I know that Minamoto does as well. Instead, we took matters into our own hands and started the JIA Weapons Co. This venture is all not-for-profit with all profits going to the JIA.
I believe that we are better off without people who quit. They, obviously, have nothing to give to the country anyway. It is a lot easier to sit back and gain from others work than actually doing the work yourself.
If people want to be lazy, they can move elsewhere as far as I am concerned. I, personally, have loved the challenge of helping Japan grow and prosper.
Long live Japan!
Great article, but there's one person that I find slightly annoying: Geno.
I was going to not post this, but after I saw a part of "private" conversation(which I'm not going to paste here, I don't want to get banned for doing nothing) where "somebody" had an announcement to make, I really feel I need to get this out of my system.
"They never became Japanese, they never tried to be... They are not what I call citizens; they are what I call a PTO group."
I'd like to see some reasons given to these statements. Lies are lies, even those told by a man who prefers writing his blog rather than doing his duties as a minister. 🙂
Since the beginning we were open to you. We told you what we were up to, we told you about our ideas and we were always completely honest. I'd say we tried to become Japanese citizens.
And you call a group of ~9-10 people who ASK you if they can join your party a PTO group? We could have just taken any party(I recall some didn't even have pp candidates back then) but we decided to try to make a contract with a tiny one - we got your party to top 5(you win) and we will not be treated as PTO group and possibly at some point some of us might run for party presidency(we win).
Instead you make a topic to hidden section of forum that those evil bastards are going to take over your party("Geno reveals a conspiracy against Japan" - points for you), you get to keep party presidency even though we could have taken it if we wanted(you win), we are treated as a PTO group, or at least we are not treated as members of your community(we lose).
Not to mention we got your party to top 5 like we promised, you didn't have anything against us back then, did you? We even let you know about ourselves long before we arrive. Is that how a PTO group acts(Hint: NO)? Stop being an egoistic big-headed moron and show some gratitude.
I wish most of you the best luck in eLife, and I thank Psi for being objective while writing this. o/
Nice article Psi.
"Steadfast devotion can only be brought about by a deep bond to the local community. It is a strongly united and friendly community that we of Japan should be proud of, and it is this that should be advertised" - I agree. that's what I want the JIA to contribute to. However, certain conditions must be met to achieve this, and a small group of us are trying to (despite the restraints).
To all Council of Zen guys: I hate to see you all leave. You've never ever done anything bad in all the time I've been here, and you were all active and often went beyond the call of duty. If you come here and live in Japan, buying our produce, contributing to politics by sharing your ideas, put hours into getting work done and always trying to be impartial towards us all- then you are Japanese until you stop doing that. You guys were Japanese, period.
I hope all your future endevours work out for you. Keep in touch and visit some time!
~Minamoto
I want Okkius Lavanche and Yaff back, NAO. That is an order soldiers. 🙁
Geno calling the Council of Zen a PTO group is ridiculous. If the Council of Zen was a PTO group then i would wish we had a group like that "PTO" Japan every day.
"Adversity does not build character; it reveals it."
As a citizen I feel that proposals to change policy pertaining to national security should involve a detailed and lengthy discussion. A nation's congress may be biased but I am inclined to believe that all members including citizens are, on a subconscious level, aware that issues related to the Imperial Army are sensitive in this country. Assuming the debate was fair, the decision made by congress should be to the satisfaction of all parties involved with the understanding that there is room for improvement.
I am also certain that one of the core values in any military organization is not to quit. Compromise, improvise and soldier on.
Questions about one's attachment and identity should have no place in these discussions because the floor is open to debate based on the assumption that it is for the betterment of the country, regardless of origins or geographical boundary.
To be fair, even I consider them a PTO at first. They were aggressive with Geno about the Orange Party at first. For a large group to come to Japan and be Aggressive about joining a party to get into Japan and change it is 'sketchy'. Nothing against many of them now because I find them fun, but you cannot blame a person for being suspicious. It was not just Geno, it was many.
Minamoto: I award you with the ZS Article-Comments Peace Prize
Tanaka: "Questions about one's attachment and identity should have no place in these discussions because the floor is open to debate based on the assumption that it is for the betterment of the country, regardless of origins or geographical boundary."
Would you be able to elaborate on this point? Because I for one think that attachment and identity is all the more important in a game such as this.
15th day is approaching, I'm going to PTO all of you. Be prepared, you have been warned...
Oraizan, that's true and we (at least I...) can understand that view, but I guess that you don't think that we were PTO group any more 😃
That is the problem with Geno's statement 😛