Demonstrating the CAF's innocence [Proofs included]
Jsboutin
😉
eCanadians,
For the last few days, accusations of corruption and of breaking the Tanking funding limit have flowed.
However, I thought that since I didn't consider Max Maher a trustable person, I couldn't trust his maths either. Here are the details proving the innocence of the CAF on the breaking of the Tanking limit, and therefore of corruption within the CAF. I hope you enjoy seeing the biggest part of the eCanadian budget is safely and honestly managed.
First off : The actual expenses:
What is the problem, here? The tanking cost in gold was converted to CAD to show how much had been used from CND in CAD value (As this was the value we were using to balance it out).
Therefore, the actual expenses were 5408,17 CAD at a conversion rate of 34 CAD/gold which was the time's price.(Maher seems to have used a higher one). Here are the sum of all expenses on Coda for that perio
😛
https://spreadsheets3.google.com/ccc?key=tudbgr3QwyaNRYX2yQy_Jpw&authkey=CJrOqKcB&hl=en#gid=0
4% of our budget from december represents about 0,04*(15k+15k+25k+25k)= 3200 CAD or so.
We are over.
We obviously can't prove that TemujinBC donated a ton of gold without donation lists.
HOWEVER, the DAL kindly donated an amount of 150G, which is not included in the budget and that can therefore be used at will. It was donated to support the war effort, and was used on tanking critical battles. seems like a good use to me.
110G was used on these 2 tanking sessions: 110 G, at 34 CAD / Gold, the time's rate, represents 3740 CAD, which we can substract from the total expenses on Coda:
5408,17 CAD - 3740 = 1668.17 CAD, which is only a bit over half the limit for a tank.
Therefore, the budget wasn't exceeded on this particular occasion, no harm was done.
Comments
voted for truth
I was so surprised to see those numbers from Maher and I am very happy to see JSBoutin having a look; Next time Maher, please recheck twice yours calculations before saying we are a bunch of kids at the HC. We are not so bad boys and we have Mary watching us all the time 😛
Jsboutin can into CGA!
Voted for CAF.
Pour ceux qui n'ont pas compris : http://www.cga-quebec.org/
this article is manufactured.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aX6XMIldkRU
DAL saved Coda's asssssssssssss
Dont forget Damien Wolf who donated 200 gold all by his lonesome.
Yeah, but I only found an article from the DAL, crisfire 😛
Cooked Books
DAL Money > government > CAF > Coda
You'd win this argument if the money went straight from the DAL to Coda, but once it went to the government, and was then given to the CAF it became part of the CAF's budget, a mid month increase if you will, in which excess was given to Coda
I remember nonstop ads saying "DAL donates Gold for War effort", not "DAL gives Gold to Coda for Tanking"...
This is a twist of information, not at all unexpected
True, DAL was a good help for this major battle by providing gold; it was and still appreciate.
voted
Rolo : This money was sent to CND to defend Canada, not to enter in the CAF's budget.
It was used, and since it was used from CND, it was booked.
Here is an idea...admit corruption exists inside your own organization and then fix it.
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck it sure as heck isn't a pigeon.
No amount of article writing is going to wash away the fact that corruption does exist. It would be so much better if just ONE HC member would come forward and say "Yeah, we screwed up and did some dirty stuff...here it is and here is how we are going to fix it"
Then you guys can start fresh and earn back the respect of the electorate.
Acacia, I can assure you that I think everything that was done was done with good intentions. If corruption exists, it's above my level, and is pretty limited de facto.
Fact is money was handed out willy nilly with no attention paid to who was getting how much and no flags were raised when a massive amount went to one person
You don't have mechanisms in place to catch this, therefor, who is to say it hasn't been abused before and won't be abused again
Voted for truth x2
We have mechanism in place, however this law had fallen out of our remembrance... fact is, it wasn't broken, though.
Voted for truth x3
We should definetly have a permanent Accountant to make sure the numbers are always right ; )
This is creative accounting, the kind where you plug money from Column A into Column B to make the numbers look good
This still doesn't address Coda's plans to siphon money from the SPP or the fact that she tanked 170,000k in Damage in a battle at 98%-2% when Chuck Norris (Not Chucky) had already deposited 250,000k
Rolo : She was given the order right before chuck Norris started in this battle...
Chuck Norris wasn't paid, he was apparently going for one of the first CHs. She should have stopped, then, but it was late and noone really made that call. mistakes are bound to happen over a month.
Nonsense
I watched that battle, She was still tanking long after Chuck had stopped. I remember it well as I had confused Chuck with Chucky and wondered WTF the CAF was doing
She most definitely Tanked AFTER Chuck was finished, in the first 15 minutes of the battle, and when we were up 98%
Here comes Rolo and Acacia to tear the country apart again. Didn't you two learn that sequels suck and nobody watches them. Especially when it is sequel number 100+.
oh and Voted Hard
I can see how a line(s) on a spreadsheet could express the same amount in CD and Gold. That could account for things. Could you tell me, then:
1. Did TemBC actually approve anything by executive order, as you and many including TemBC have been saying for days now, or was that just an invention.
2. If it was not an invention, and there actually was an oral executive order, who made the mistake in the first place: who advised him that such an order was required, who did the math originally.
3. This "I looked at the math again" sounds familiar, since I recently read that lukepeters "found" a 200 gold leakage that was subsequently explained. Are these the same things or is there another 200 gold accounting error. If they are the same, would it demonstrate greater good faith and honesty to acknowledge his role.
4 If there is a different 200 gold hole, what was it?
5 Did the CAF provide, to an individual, more than 4% of its budget. If so, how are you demonstrating "CAF's innocence" as stated in the headline? The "we can anything we want if we get more than the initial budget" seems pretty weak to me.
6. Do you agree that "errors" do not constitute "corruption"? And that there is something to be said for both sides, 'cause reasonable and honest men can disagree?
😁^Answer this madman.
Voted for thruth x4 and hard too
I don't vote falsity.
Voted for truth x5?
Looks cleaner then a whistle to me!
On day 1133, Coda receved 2070 CAD and 60g plus another 200 CADaccording to this document. I don't know how do you reduced it to 360 CAD.
So actually, she have received 8638.36 CAD. Don't try to change the number without justification.
And why do you subtract 110g from the supplie that Coda have received? It's doesn't make sense. Actually just add the 150g that you have received in the CAF budget for the month. That being done. It is 80 000 CAD + 150*34 = 85100
4%*85100= 3404 CAD. She has still received about 5000 more than the Cap limit.
Again, you just try to hide the fact that you have exceed the limit. Don't try to fool people with playing with the numbers. Everyone know that the CAF try to hide that they have give more than allowed to Coda.
1) The HC try to raise the Cap to 10% in CDC without success
2) The HC vigorously and even aggressively reject all requests to make the document public again in CDC.
3) The HC try to say that there was an Executive Order when Congress has never been informed of that,
4) And now you try to play with the numbers.
What will be your next attempt? Add the SPP donation to the budget?
😁😁😁😁^Butthurt
uh...
@HC,
I told you to just admit to the error and propose fixing future abuses. You are getting nothing done with this article. Yes you won a battle but you're going to lose the war of Public Relations if you keep this up.
Judging by the comments in this article, you would have saved your self a lot of bitter division.
Those who liked you before will like you now as well, those who didn't will only get more bitter. You solved nothing.
Bad move on the part of the CAF PR team.
I dunno why you made the title "Demonstrating CAF's innocence"
If I were you, I would be disassociating the blame from the institution by framing it as "Demonstrating (leader goes here)'s innocence"
"Demonstrating (steve?)'s innocence"
"We obviously can't prove that TemujinBC donated a ton of gold without donation lists."
?? Do you not keep track of cash and gold inflows as well as the outflows?
In my opinion, it's still a lot of gold for a few people.
SHE TOOK MY MONEY
WHEN I'M NEED
SHE'S A TRIFLING FRIEND INDEED
@olivermellors
No, I did not keep track of the gold I donated to the Canadian War fund, in order to save Canada from the French and UK. Damian Wolf donated 200 gold. the DAL donated 150. Others donated some. I gave well over 400 gold to several tanks in the nfld RW, Ontario battle, and Quebec liberation, as well as my own personal tanking. I did not keep track of these numbers, as I never expected compensation or remuneration from the government (neither did Damian or the DAL).
I'd like to state for the record that anyone who criticizes Coda or the CAF supply personnel for supposed "misappropriation of funds" during the period of Dec 5th-Jan 5th should recognize that I was at the helm. I controlled the bank accounts, and authorized every and all tanking payments. If any of you wish to question my strategic decisions with regards to tanking, fine. I'll take on all comers.
Coda tanked where she was directed to tank, at the request and timing of the President of Canada, TemujinBC.
Hugs and Kisses.
the DAL kindly donated an amount of 150G... eat it, DAL haters!
And Tem has spoken.
@Max Maher is such a butthurt that he didn't notice that 60g *34 CAD/G = approx.... Oh, right, 2040, which is incredibly near that 2070, as the rate was probably a bit over 34 CAD/G.
Voted for truth x5
Even thought we reduced what Coda had received of 2070 CAD, she still have received more than 3000 CAD over the Cap's limit...
Funding caps don't win wars.
and if the CAF didn't spend the money Rolo would have it.
Again, it doesn't make sense to subtract the 110g that Coda have received for tanking because supposedly it come from a DAL donation. Otherwise, the way you count it, it's like if the DAL has donate 110g directly to Coda instead to the Canadian Civil Defence.
You have add the 150g to the CAF's budget for the month, that being done, she have received more than 3000 CAD after she have exceeded the Cap.
You are just playing with the number and try to said that I did I mistake, which if had have, doesn't affect the fact that the cap has been exceeded.
Donations do not enter budgeted amounts.
Now please either stop complaining or at least stop complaining about things that you don't need to complain about.
Maher don't like to see his country defended.
Maher is a terrorist.