There's Gold In Them Thar (Foreign) Hills
Moishe
DATELINE: Washington, D.C. June 10,2009 - What is it with the United State Congress? Just because someone is called an "Expert" does it make them one? I am speaking, of course, of our so-called "Economic Advisers". Do these people have their heads, erm, in the clouds?
Congress, upon advisement of their Economic Advisers, is considering the complete removal of all Import Taxes (or rather reducing them to the minimum which amounts to the same thing.) What is their reasoning? "Well, we hope that the other guys will do the same thing."
And I hope that my son will meet a nice Jewish girl and give me some grand babies but it ain't gonna happen!
But why not, Moishe? You might ask.
Where is the incentive? If you let me sell stuff in your store for nothing and I am charging you double what you make to sell in my store why should I change? What are you going to give me? You've already given me your store!
If they do not go along with the plan we will embargo them!
Sure we will. We are going to embargo Romania? I doubt that. We are going to embargo Finland? Sweden? Switzerland? the UK?
If you believe that I want some of whatever you have been smoking.
One of our leading Economic experts says that when a country sells in another country they take the other countries gold out of that country thus making them weaker. Wiser words were never spoken. EXCEPT this very same "expert" is encouraging the USA to lower ALL Import Taxes to the barest minimum. So Romania sells here but to sell there we face a 99% Import Tax. Roughly the same in Sweden. In fact most other countries (but I admit not all) have higher Import Taxes than the good old USA.
So which way is the gold going? Who is getting weaker because their gold is leaving the country?
BUT, he says, it will make weapons cheaper for us! Sure it will. Does anyone with a lick of sense thing another country is going to sell to us what they need for their selves? If they are selling weapons here it is because they are making more off them than if they sell then at home.
I've tried over the last year - even during my time in Congress - to let these experts know the facts. But you can not tell anyone something when they already know it all.
One: We do not want Diamond or Iron companies in the USA because they are a losing venture. Then set the Income Tax on those type companies to something outrageous. (What was the argument - but we want them all the same.) WHY? Just to have them the same? Reminds me of when Congress wanted to set ALL TAXES the same to "see what happens".
People, there is too damn much "let's see what happens" with the policies of Congress.
You want to know what will happen if you set Import Taxes to the minimum? You will see a whole lot of foreign goods coming into the country without any chance of recouping that in their country. And why should we? If they can sell it cheaper here how can we compete there? Especially when they do not lack the sense to maintain a degree of protection for their companies.
So we are told "we have too many companies". Who is Congress to tell Americans that they have too many of anything? Congress is supposed to be serving the people. And yet they are trying to control the people. Plus lower our standard of living.
I do not want to send more gold to Romania or anywhere else.
If you agree then get on the eUSA Forums and tell Congress how you feel.
Comments
First to do what?
I agree, and I'm not even IN America. You guys should have 99% import on wood, oil, and grain at least. I asked one congressman what the deal was. His reply:
"Congress wants to see what happens".
Hell of a reason "to see what happens". What should happen is every one of them should be voted out of office and then told, "See? THAT is what happens!"
I am so glad someone else has figured out that the primary purpose of the American government is to better the lives of Americans. Not to forge alliances vith varmongering nations, not to design import tax levels to benefit trade in other countries, but to improve the standard of living for those committed to staying in the eUS. That's it. That's all I vant from my government, to represent its citizens and partnering vith them to improve their lots in life.
Arjay, you and I actually agree on this one. The economic system in eRep is mercantilist and thus favors protectionist policies.
Let's hope that Congress gets its collective heads out of the sand and corrects this after we see our exports drop and imports rise dramatically.
Good argument,
voted!
Welcome to USWP reasoning. "You disagree? Well, sit down and shut up!"
Let's see what happens isn't policy, economic or otherwise. It is guess work. And if you really wanted to "see what happens" why not try it out on one resource or one industry and not ruin the entire US economy in one move? Why not, because the USWP doesn't give a sh-t and Scrabman has been in one term too many.
When I saw those import taxes begin to drop about a week ago, a piece of me died.
voted and subscribed.
"It's the economy, stupid!"
I'll be writing to my Congress Rep next, see what their position is and express this voter's view.
I believe it's "Thar"
Also why wont your son have Grandbabies? Ghey?
Anyway, I think it's a more of an all or nothing sort of thing. Congress in no way is going to go for 99% imports (even though they should), but it's illogical to have 20-30% import taxes too. Go entirely one way or the the other, don't half-ass it, at least they're finally making a decision. Well I use the term "Making a decision" lightly, most of Congress is just agreeing with what the guy before you said, and then disagreeing with anyone who comes after.
Voted for an old friend 😉
Voted for this Old Friend... Weird how things stay the same as much as they change here...
No one ever thinks long term only just doing what their friends do...
Voted
disagree.
The value of the USD is so low compared to other currencies that american companies will still be able to sell their goods. If the drp in import taxes leads to a world wide drop then with our low currency we can not help but rake it in.
Oh lord...This is a horrifying glimpse into Congress...
HAHA OH WOW
When I was told that they were lowering import, I assumed that our allies were doing the same thing. Because I didn't think that congress was a bunch of idiots. Man was I wrong.
Great article. Something no one has mentioned however, is that with lower wages (caused by the stupidest tax policy EVER, ANYWHERE) we will have lower gov't revenue. This of course will lead to us being basically defenseless or at least have a complete disability to project eAmerican power anywhere. Put simply, this will destroy our armed forces and turn us into a 3rd world country.
Im there with you my friend. Ive been fighting this BS from the moment I was informed of it. I really wish our govenrment would pull there heads out of there butts on this one. This is not going to help us at all in fact we are just making ourselves into the cheap hore of the global economy.
I have voted NO on every single one of these measures (as has ssomo). It's nice to know I'm not the only one to disagree with what's going on. Everyone, please go to the forums (http://eusforum.com/index.php) and thoroughly express your disapproval in the "Congress" board.
What do you expect from a majority USWP congress?
@St Krems: According to what I have read in the forums foreign countries have pretty much told us to go shove it on dropping their import taxes. They intend to protect their markets. Regretfully our Congress does not see likewise.
subscribed and voted
The eUS's low import taxes and high income taxes are a major issue. When businesses aren't protected from foreign competition, they don't make very much money, and when businesses don't make very much money, they pass that on to their employees, who already pay among the highest income taxes in the eWorld... does anyone have remote knowledge of economics in Congress?
I very much disagree with you. Mercantilism is a highly ineffective way of running an economy. Tariffs are only a hindrance to international trade and this sort of protectionist thinking only results in higher-priced goods, both domestic and imported. Admittedly I'm pretty new here so it could be that the game mechanics are an abysmal representation of the real world economy, but if not you are promoting Socialism.
In this particular situation, the eUS will not benefit from international trade (except in iron and diamonds) because it's just about the only country where it's just as easy, if not easier, for foreign companies to sell as in their home countries. In other words, it's not trade, it's just Romanians being able to flood all the industries and drive prices down while American companies can't do the same thing over there.
@Cayto: I would support free trade if our "allies" also did so BUT when we have 1% Import Tax and our allies run from 50% to 99% then there needs to be a change.
Reread the article. I am not promoting protectionism for its sake. I am promoting an equal trading field.