The most powerful man in eCanada
Rigour6
Imagine an entire nation about to have a referendum over just one person.
It may sound absurd, but that’s what eCanada is about to do.
At issue is whether the nation should grant an unconditional pardon to a former CP who used his position to steal between 5000 and 6000 gold from the nation.
An outsider might assume that this pardon is being considered because the individual has reformed and everyone deserves a second chance. In fact, almost the precise opposite is true. The thief has consistently rejected all attempts of reconciliation, including an offer of a fellow citizen to reduce the restitution to the nation to only 480 gold – less than a tenth of the amount stolen. The thief has used his ill-gotten gains to build influence, and has recently embarked on domestic terrorism to take over other political parties, thus reducing the democratic choice given to his fellow citizens and leaving the nation vulnerable to PTO attempts from outside.
His excuses are almost textbook sociopathy. We apparently “want” him to be the villain because he makes things “interesting”.
When Congress recently decided to grant this individual an unconditional pardon, many of those who had tolerated this barnacle of a teammate reached their breaking point. A number of the nation’s very top players began voting with their feet, abandoning the society in which they had for years become deserving pillars.
After originally suggesting that a referendum was an appropriate response if the Congress rejected a pardon but NOT if they approved one, the CP has been forced to beat a retreat and has now called for a referendum on the issue. Not surprisingly, those who have emigrated will be disenfranchised.
It is of no matter. Despite his attempts to buy votes, the thief’s pardon will struggle to exceed 40% of the votes cast, as the silent majority has made it clear for some time they really don’t want to exonerate this sort of behaviour, much less encourage it. That has become doubly clear now that the true cost of such a stand in terms of lost teammates has been tangibly demonstrated.
In the referendum, it is not even clear to me for which side the thief himself will vote. He has become so enamoured of his role as a domestic terrorist, I doubt he would want to give it up. In the past, there have been many appeals to his “better nature” – all have been sharply, snidely rebuffed.
The sad fact is that, even now, as the team faces a wide vote without trappings or roleplay on the issue, the thief continues to threaten his supposed teammates. eCanada thus faces two choices: it can give this guy a free pass and he will continue to act the villain albeit in a smaller team because of the many emigrants, or they can continue to hold to the position that stealing from the team is not to be excused and he will continue to accelerate his domestic terrorist activities. The obvious third option, that there would be a rapprochement and that the thief would at least agree to stop being a nuisance, is not even on the table. The thief makes no promises to alter his behaviour in the slightest.
And so even now, the one man who actually has the power to heal a nation through even the smallest act of contrition and reform refuses to budge. Not one inch.
There is a saying in eCanada: A nation at peace – there had to be a sacrifice.
The sacrifice in this case would be just a small amount of a single player’s pride. A simple “you guys were wrong to impeach me, but I shouldn’t have stolen the gold – my bad” would probably do. Or an indication that enough’s enough, and from here forward the player will seek to turn over another leaf and follow Wheaton’s Law.
I predict no such reassurance, as tiny and as inexpensive as it would be to offer, will be forthcoming.
The entire nation is rift, and in some cases it has descended into civil war, with former eCanadians even taking up arms against their old teammates.
And so a nation of two thousand players will burn.
All in the service of one man’s petty vanity.
A man who, even now, could end it all with little more than a single sentence.
A sentence he will not utter.
And so eCanada has become a Greek tragedy. And those of us who left, not in anger but in sadness, gaze back and can only shake our heads at what our beloved enation has become.
N by NE Volume 2, Number 1
UPDATE: The eCanadian CP has now rescinded his call for a referendum, in effect returning to his original pro-pardon position. Expect a hardening of positions on both sides now, and further emigration as some choose to wage a de facto civil war.
Comments
not just look back...but tank against not us but our alliance.
When we get wiped will those who did so utter anything other than "I told you so?"
I think were a little to far past bury the hatchet heal a nation Rigour.
We are, Rylde. But it bears remembering how far that people were willing to bend towards rapprochement - with nothing in return - before they broke.
good article, thnx
@Acacia: I for one do not subscribe to the theory that it has become "necessary to destroy the village in order to save it."
That said, I am not surprised by this development. You may look in your messages from, what was it?, almost two weeks ago, when I predicted that all hell was going to break loose.
And yet in stead of banding together, standing against the problem together, united in a cause, people chose to run and fight against that nation....... This is not a "burn eCanada and from the ashes we will come back and rebuild...." when the time comes to rebuild, we will remember who stood and fought, and who ran and fought against..........
TL😉R - Who's the most powerful man in the nation?
I like that fact that I've been given 4 days to show vast reforms. Because the game has not turned into orgasmic delight for all players in those 4 days, I must have not changed my ways
interesting analysis and conclusion
I can only speak for myself. I did not chose to run and fight against my country. I stayed and fought against this sort of selfish play for years. And when the team said, "No, no, that's fine, an unconditional pardon for the thief", I just walked away.
There is no way to burn eCanada to the ground and there is no way to rebuild, because you cannot rebuild anything on a foundation of selfish play. All you can do is plant crops which the selfish player will then harvest. Well, not me.
I sounded the alarm on this a looooong time ago. Some got it. Many trolled and hurled abuse. I ran for public office many times. SVTs were organized against me to ensure my defeat. I am not bitter. The team is ultimately the culmination of the many decisions it makes, some big, some little. A big decision was made to pardon the thief. The corollary to that decision (perhaps not understood by those who made it, although perhaps it was) is that I and others who share my belief in team play would no longer be part of the team.
Now there is wailing and gnashing of teeth about those who have left, who frankly read like a who's who of society builders in eCanada. Now comes their evisceration for abandoning the fight. Were even a tenth of that energy have been directed at standing up for a principle as simple as "stealing from the team is wrong", we would not be at this place.
"And so a nation of two thousand players will burn.
All in the service of one man’s petty vanity."
And so eCanada will burn...
@Rolo: coming from just today, from you, and I quote:
" the choice really boils down to you can either have me as a minor nuisance (as I am now) and possibly even a productive citizen or a Constant threat, and by constant, I mean relentless....month in and month out."
Leaving aside your false modesty that you are a "minor nuisance" and your obvious blackmail, let's just say you've missed every opportunity to actually give an unambiguous expression of reform in the past, and I expect you to miss this one as well.
The pardon was an attempt to fix things have 2 years of struggle, because this was going absolutely nowhere. The ban wasn't efficient and we were loosing as a nation the control over our political module.
Sure, some people didn't agree with it. Some decide to quit eCanada. I respect their choice, and it was their right. But, now as kind of revenge, they try to create dissent. Those who complains has left the country, and we now know what they really stand for.
The nation do not burn from the inside. It burns from the outside. Stop playing for yourself and play for the team for godshake.
Well Max, I would disagree with much of your analysis but I would agree with you on one central point. Prior to the pardon, this matter was largely in a standoff. You had thief who wouldn't reform, and a nation which didn't condone thievery.
Pardoning the thief has taken that situation out of that standoff and has made it more flexible.
And now we will see if the people who for a long time have said "Rolo makes things interesting" like how interesting it has become.
By the way, there's a reason why the Chinese consider "may you live in interesting times" to be a curse.
Each of us has our way of looking at this, but for me, I am content with my choice - even though I resent being forced to make it.
Voted!
"You had thief who wouldn't reform, and a nation which didn't condone thievery."
Thievery has always be condone in eCanada. Forum ban were given to 1ronman, Rolo, Wes Lewis, Mg( aka SAWC), TemujinBC, Pimpdollaz, and more recently EZstreet.
I agree with with that a pardon isn't easy to swallow. You need to get over your principle. But, what is the point of having a forum ban apply to someone for a such long time that meanwhile the guy banned has gather so much manpower, that slowly all the forums community is loosing in-game control over political module?
Can I remind you all parties that has been PTO by Rolo group since he's ban?
DAL, UN, MOO and CPP. EPIC is likely to be the next target. The pardon was an attempt to avoid that. Unfortunately, it looks like it would be veto again.
Then, do you prefer to have a forum with no ban, no court and let people do whatever they want ingame, without forum monotoring? Soon, I guess will have to that conclusion, as forum would become useless.
good article, thanks
Max, I am not sure what point you are making but to me it sounds suspiciously like, "Rolo made himself such a nuisance that the best thing to do was just to surrender."
If that's what you meant to say, agree to disagree.
Rigour: yours was the same choice made by many, before and after. Jacobi decided much earlier. He saw 24 ply deep. So did you but you have a more hopeful heart. And you keep trying to help. What you say is, though eloquent, not surprising. It is a description. It is accurate.
The article's central message is being ignored, however. This time the distraction is tanking by Fritz and Ralph. Everyone wants to talk about that. 1 ply deep.
oops.. now see the Chief's post which is on point.
So.. I prefer no referendum at all. the pardon's done. Best to not try and undo it for some of the reasons you mention. But do acknowledge that it was a bad mistake made in good faith. Acknowledge it publicly, fully and repeatedly. What do you think?
loved the article - thank you for it.
Keeping Rolo banned fix nothing. Rolo will continue to PTO parties as he did, and seeking to gain more control over the elections.
Restoring his access could help to fix this problems.
The sad thing is it will not work now. Selfish players decided that their own interest were more important than fixing our political module.
Max, it is a strange worldview where the "selfish players" of which you speak, the Klines, the Lawrences, the Fritzhill's, etc are seen as the problem but Rolo gets a free pass.
Max, you are surrendering to Rolo. Has banning rolo been overly effective? No, but that doesn't justify an unconditional pardon where we prove to everyone that you can steal as much as you want and not have any repercussions as long as you are good enough at being annoying. I'm not completely against pardoning rolo, but I need to see rolo pay back some of that gold and stop being a pain in eCanada's backside prior to us giving a pardon...a gesture of goodwill to show that he truly wants back in our society.
I like the title, but it would also be apt to use "The Most Powerful on the Cinder" to complement your other Watchmen quote.
Yeah, you said it right R6...bonfire of the vanity, and mainly singular in this case.
Any one got a plan to get Rolo to leave or give back the gold?
Attacking each other does not seem to be working out well for us.
@E😨 No, there is no such plan. This, as has been pointed out has never been about him, it has been about how we as a team choose to react to him. As long as our choice was stand for what was right, a goodly number of players were prepared to stay out and do the best they could to build the nation, despite the fact there as guy coming along behind them burning it up. Once the team made the decision to condone theft, those same players couldn't accept that. Et voila.
eCanada is an elephant that never forgets
http://bit.ly/z2xURl
Thanks Rigour.
Good read, althought I don't think I'll go fighting against eCan, the legislative body made a choice to ''unite'' the country. They now have the opportunity to live with it.
As for myself, they sent out a declaration that you can steal and threaten people and be rehabilitated without any signs of goodwill, as long as you are annoying enought.
Ofc banning and the status quo wasn't solving anything. But at least it was sending the right message, that the country expect you to have a slightly integre behavior, now it's all gone to teh shitter.
IF you guys are ok with that fine, I'm not. And that's why I enjoy my stay in the US right now.
^ this
I spoke for uniting for too long. Instead of support the public decided to continue to undermind efforts and back a thief. In the end this has been long coming. I'm all for a MTO, it's been too long coming.
Greek Tragedy. What an apt, sad description.
I thought you left
just cant let go
We should pressure TEDEN to annex eCanada. The alliance wouldn't suffer as much this way in comparison to a formerly stalwart alliance member self-combusting, and Rolo would have a much much tougher time peddling his influence in the much larger combined community of eUSA + eCanada
^ you can always count on lucasmon for a stupid idea
thanks lucasmon