Taxes
Day 652, 13:34
•
Published in Peru 
•
by
•
by tatters
http://erepublikperu.foroactivo.com/lobby-del-congreso-f35/tax-system-t599.htm?sid=0e5ecf37106f308fb97660ecc0c9faf8
in this topic Minister of Economy - Gilroy from Partido de Excelencia Peruana presented tax reform project.We were willing to discuss it but unfortunately forum administration don't want to or can't grant our congressmen access to congressional forum. So in this article we will try to present flaws in proposed tax system and show our own.
First of all let's take a close look on taxes in foreign countries with high iron
income tax import tax VAT
Greece 10% 20-30%(manu) 5%
Brazil 10% 75-99% 1%
Russia 5% 40-99% 1%
Indonesia 10% 99% 1%
Hungary 5-15% 50-99% 5%
As you can see all of these countries have lower vat than income tax. Main reason of this policy is that with high VAT comes black market. VAT is very easy to bypass. Doing same thing with income tax takes too much time and majority of people is simply too lazy for that. Thats the main reason why we should have higher income tax than VAT.
Our proposal of taxes:
income tax import tax VAT
weapon/gifts/tickets 12% 50% 1%
food 12% 50% 3%
oil/diamonds 12% 1% -
grain/wood/iron 12% 50% -
12% income tax will give constant revenue and won't be inconvenient for regular worker.
Low Vat will increase demand on Peruwian products by lowering their cost. This will increase consumption, revenue and enhance economy.
Please, all interested state your opinnion in comments
in this topic Minister of Economy - Gilroy from Partido de Excelencia Peruana presented tax reform project.We were willing to discuss it but unfortunately forum administration don't want to or can't grant our congressmen access to congressional forum. So in this article we will try to present flaws in proposed tax system and show our own.
First of all let's take a close look on taxes in foreign countries with high iron
income tax import tax VAT
Greece 10% 20-30%(manu) 5%
Brazil 10% 75-99% 1%
Russia 5% 40-99% 1%
Indonesia 10% 99% 1%
Hungary 5-15% 50-99% 5%
As you can see all of these countries have lower vat than income tax. Main reason of this policy is that with high VAT comes black market. VAT is very easy to bypass. Doing same thing with income tax takes too much time and majority of people is simply too lazy for that. Thats the main reason why we should have higher income tax than VAT.
Our proposal of taxes:
income tax import tax VAT
weapon/gifts/tickets 12% 50% 1%
food 12% 50% 3%
oil/diamonds 12% 1% -
grain/wood/iron 12% 50% -
12% income tax will give constant revenue and won't be inconvenient for regular worker.
Low Vat will increase demand on Peruwian products by lowering their cost. This will increase consumption, revenue and enhance economy.
Please, all interested state your opinnion in comments
😉and forum administration, please grant our congressmen access to forum.
😉
Facebook
Twitter
Discord
Comments
FIRST!
sekend!
definitely agreed. voted.
and Spain?? ....
votado
agreed this part, and Jackox is maniac
I am not a congressman. I am Minister of Economy.
...Eunited states???
seguimos en ingles un congreso que inentendiblemente en un pais latino se expresa a su pueblo en ingles... y ni siquiera ponen una traduccion.....
viva ePeru!!
q poco patriotismo..!!
nadie defiende a su patria!!
es un polaco, como kieres q hable castellano.
aunke igual puede pasar el translator
es lo minimo que deberia hacer si se mete a gobernar un pais (que no lo corresponde) de habla hispana!!
Creo que es todo lo contrario, el VAT es más trabajoso de eludir que el INCOME. El INCOME lo eludes pagando a los trabajadores por donación y las empresas traspasan dinero por el MM.
Votaré en contra de su propuesta por lo explicado arriba 🙂
Espero que pronto tengan acceso al foro del Congreso.
Saludos.
pfft lol lol lol
Look at tatters donation list and that of the ones he works with. It appears, although I could be wrong, that tatters is an active black market player. There is nothing wrong wih this - it is perfectly legal.
But assuming that VAT truly is more difficult to circumvent, then black marketeers would certainly be lining up tax plans favoring income taxes over VAT systems.
Mira la lista de la donación hecha jirones y la de los que trabaja. Parece ser, aunque puedo estar equivocado, que es un harapos jugador activo en el mercado negro. No hay nada malo WIH esto - es perfectamente legal.
Pero suponiendo que el VAT es realmente más difícil de eludir, a continuación, negro mercaderes duda sería alinear los planes fiscales que favorecen a los impuestos sobre los ingresos respecto de los sistemas de VAT.
No estoy de acuerdo con el aumento del impuesto sobre la renta. Mantener el 10% está bien. PEN va a subir y el sueldo se va a caer ahora. No cabe duda de que el salario real de ePeruvian será dado de baja después de 12% de impuestos de ingresos.
We don't know for certain what impact taxes have because no one has ever completed an income analysis and proposed a budget.
Hypothetically, if someone had bad intentions they would like to increase taxes to put more money in the treasury to steal in a TO.
No sabemos a ciencia cierta qué impacto tienen los impuestos, porque nadie ha completado un análisis de los ingresos y propuso un presupuesto.
Hipotéticamente, si alguien tiene malas intenciones que les gustaría aumentar los impuestos para poner más dinero en la tesorería de robar en un TO.
Other than Hungary, all of the foreign taxes you posted were in the 5-10% range... when then would you show them as an example, while proposing 12% income tax?
It's not like ePeru is a socialist nation that is funding food/moving tickets/gifts/weapons to it's citizens. There is no need for a 12% income tax.
If programs are proposed to build hospitals, and provide more services to the populace, then I could understand the desire to increase tax revenue... but increasing taxes, be they income or VAT, would accomplish nothing other than stuffing the pockets of a privileged few.
Coming from a party that is accused of PTO; a party that has been accused of robbing the Bolivian treasury, raising income taxes for no apparent reason does nothing to promote your image.
Before you start talking taxes, how about you start talking about social reform?