Some Inconvenient Truths.
Dubhthaigh
Good evening, citizens. I come back to comment on some things I see in the Media. Read on if you like.
Inconvenient Truth One: Nothing has changed.
Those promising 'change' have few, if any real ideas for the better. The whole damn election is like a comedy that hits the theatre every month - except its not funny anymore. Even the title stays the same - "Vote for change." Seriously guys, a good president could come up with something move inventive.
I have seen criticism of the IDF from two presidential candidates and one political commentator. As I have not been around much I am sure there has been a whole lot more in addition to this. Well:
Inconvenient Truth Two: The idea that the IDF structure was outdated, insufficient or at fault for failure over the last few weeks is farcical, untrue and no better than fiction.
I'm sorry, but thats just the way it is. The IDF is based heavily on the UK military - the very people who thwarted us. Having been in the eUK military and having created the current IDF system, I know what i'm talking about. The system works, is simple, and probably one of the best around.
So why does the IDF suck?
Inconvenient Truth Three: Any system is only as strong as the people in it.
Or perhaps more relevantly - those who can be bothered to be a part of it. Whilst a few dedicated players tried their best throughout the duration of the new IDF, 2 of the 3 IDF critics did not report for one battle, sign up, or take the induction test. This leads me on to my next point:
Inconvenient Truth Four: Most of the people who are criticising and proposing change have absolutely no clue idea what they are talking about.
It's actually beyond funny now. Why do they even bother? Although, what isn't amusing is that a large number of people lap it up like it's the finest f***ing champagne around. Why must this country be the proverbial 'gullible kid in the playground.'
Perhaps I should list some real reasons why we lost:
1. Too many enemies.
2. Too many Irish in paramilitaries - before, this caused a lack of central command on the field, then/now it means that the IDF doesnt have the manpower to produce what it needs.
3. People didnt bother to carry out the system properly, especially since a quartermasters office was never created.
4. Its impossible to perpetually hold a non-original region.
What I am fed up with seeing:
1. People who do little or nothing to improve the country when its in need, yet suddenly feel able to help around election time.
2. People who play on popular notions like 'Army sucks' or 'we need more community.' You might as well just 'I have no real policies, so i'll pander to the common conception/what sounds good.
3. People who have no idea about, or have made no effort to change/take part in the things they criticise
What I want to see in a presidential candidate:
1. Someone who has offered changes for the better, even when they arent running for office.2
2. Someone who has attempted to institute their changes.
3. Someone capable of instituting change.
4. Someone able to stick to their principles, even when the tide of media absurdity is against them.
5. Someone who can inspire a sense of community in Ireland.
6. Someone who will/did not prostitute themselves to the public insanity and agree with absurd analyses of the situation.
The question you should ask yourself on election day is: Which candidate has actually done that?
/End Rant.
Comments
Fully and vociferously agree.
We have a modern UK command and control system with a logistics system based on a concept introduced in March 2009...
No point having a such a command structure without the materiél to back it.
Up da 'Ca!
No we dont Brian. Every part of the IDF is new.
What is evident is that A: The system wasnt followed (no quartermasters on 24/7 to supply weapons) and B: Weapons were not distributed as some would like.
Neither is a fualt of the system. Both are human errors.
Up da CA!
Dubhthaigh, our reliance on poorly run state companies for weapons and food has not changed since March 2009.
FACT.
o7 Up the 'CA!
Official sign of the ICA Commander
Séamus Fearon
Up da 'Ca!!
o7 Up the 'CA!
Up the CA!
Up the CA!!!
The fact you are using a critique of individuals as a platform for advertising the ICA shows immaturity, ignorance and generally the same kind of culture of misinformation that has deprived the army of the state of valuable members for little reason.
Unite and work together. Answer to the people. Do not incite division and idiocy.
Up the 'CA!
Shut up Al
Hello Dubh. Once again a well thought out and hard to debate statement. I'll be the first to admit that the system didn't work as it should have but it was not the fault of the system. Human error and unlucky circumstances are to blame. I will admit I for one could have done better but I am trying to be part of the solution and not part of the problem.
Up the 'CA!!
Dubh, enjoy the ICA response, your article will soon be voted higher and faster than you anticipate, in other words, we are uniting and working together, collectively to better the position of your article. The ICA is a cohesive group, one that is thriving, benefiting each member, and therefore working to improve Ireland everyday. Collectively we are the ICA, individually we are Irish citizens or in some instances friends of Ireland, we also want to see improvement and the betterment of our country. As for unity, We work seamlessly with the IDF when we are on the battlefield, so despite being a separate militia, we are united in times of war, which is where the ICA shines. Additionally, we have and will continue to donate weapons and food to any and all Irish, when our stock quantities allow, not just ICA members.
Liliam x2. ICA ABU
Do not leave. Loved this line ". People who do little or nothing to improve the country when its in need, yet suddenly feel able to help around election time."
Dubh -1
Up Da 'CA
@Dubhthaigh
You have been away for a while.
I just want to clarify that I never said that the "IDF sucks", because it doesn't suck. It far from sucks. There are lots of great people in it and it is a good association. There was however a supply problem with it this term and Anthony Colby the co-MoDefence agrees that existed.
I don't think that's the systems fault, all that was needed were a few more people to supply weapons. It's not rocket science, it's simple.
The change that I was talking about is not just a change in government, it's a change in how the whole government operates. I'll outline this later on in an article.
But it's really great.
If I was unclear there was an issue with one battle. RL commitments and bad timing resulted in there being less than perfect coverage for supply. All this fuss started after the loss of NI. If there was an issue before I did not hear about it. Where were all the articles complaining about supply then? My statement that I could have done better is my philosophy that no one is perfect and can do better.
And Dubh only announced he was leaving 6 days ago.
Lliam x3! or Liliam x3, as Pete says. I love this guy. What a verbose bastard. Up the 'CA! Micktrim o/ Good to see you. A true eIrish hero has returned. Still, I am a memeber of the IDF and a fan of Dubby. Damn, I'm conflicted.
Up the Irish Countrywomans Association!
http://www.ica.ie/
Nah,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_Citizen_Army
And the e-version,
http://irishcitizenarmy.forumotion.com
Nice to see Sean Powers plugging his knitting club too, good for you mate!
I can definitely agree with this.
I'm sick of your cuntery Dubh... and sick of looking at Bullet Points now too.
Up Da 'CA
"Someone who has offered changes for the better, even when they arent running for office"
Yes.