Martinoz's answer for Josh Frost statement.
Webi88
Original article can be found here.
I got permission of the author to publish this article in USA.
Probably most of you already noticed Josh Frost's article about USA leaving EDEN.
After reading this article I was angry, but from the other side- happy. He[Josh Frost] doesn't even know how stupid these words were. He forgot that USA exists only because EDEN helped them to stop PEACE during 3rd World War. He forgot as well that USA wouldn't manage to get Karnataka only by themselves.
1.USA is the only EDEN country to gain High Iron - this is the fact and noone can argue with that. Since then, cash that flows in and out from this org grown to enermous amount. It isn't a secret, that member of American Army are part of congress and cabinet. It isn't a secret either that Marines got their napoleon training sponsored. Around 30 % of American Budget is spent on military(proven by donation list) and failing to secure Karnataka would bring tragic results. President of USA at that moment- Josh Frost.
2. Peace with France. Noone could explain this peace agreement. Everyone knew that this move is senceless. Usa have signed peace treaty with France(USA had 10 MPP's activated) absolutely for free. Article of Frost explaining this move can be found here. In this article we can read, that peace between America and France can secure from getting blocked by France during military actions(sic!).
"Closing the war with France was controversial at first, but I think it had many short term and long term benefits." As a short term benefit we could think of quick removing France from world map. As we all know few weeks after this pieace treaty Spain have attacked France, but instead of short and cheap war(which we could obtain with USA's MPP's), it ended up with 2 month's long war.
3. Sindh tanking - It is indeed one of the biggest tactic and strategic fails in last couple of months. Explanation of tanking in useless RW was really ridicolous- "Because Serbia is a threat for Karnataka". Here I can agree, Serbia is a threat, but without Croatia with it's active MPP's against Hungary and Serbia, threat is bigger then it has ever been. Instead of helping Croatia on its way to Asia, USA decided to tank in pointless battle. If american stratgist though that Sindh is origin region of India, then they should attend geography lessons more often.
4.Not attacking London during RW in NoB - USA meant to launch attack on London, in order to drain Phoenix damage. If such situation happened Phoenix would have to decide either to defend NoB or London. Sadly we will never know what could be the results of that. Explanation? "We were not prepared for attacking London." Now tell me, do you need special prepatation for a battle which is officialy a damage drain? That happened during Josh Frost presidency.
5. What made me feeling funny was, that USA feels like a country which is doing a lot to everyone in EDEN and gets nothing back. Or well, it isnt even funny, it is pathetic. USA is a country which gained more then any other country in EDEN. Lets take a look.
Poland- High Grain, High Wood, ability to swap to North and South America
Spain- same as Poland.
USA- High Iron in Karnataka, presence in Asia, ability to swap into Europe.
Croatia- ability to swap into North America or Asia(or hold on, they would have such ability if not Sindh tanking).
Josh Frost in his statement said, that USA could and should leave EDENand that he is supporting such action. What I can say is: If you want to go, feel free to do that- Im sure that if such situation happens Karnataka will be lost by USA within no time.
________________________________________ ____
END OF MARTINOZ's ARTICLE
________________________________________ ____
What Martinoz forgot is, that direct result of Sindh tanking is situation, which is happening right now in Poland. Because Prekumrje was lost, and Slovenia secured, Poland is facing Slovenia with its 6 MPP's active(containing Brazil, Serbia, UK, Russia, Indonesia and Tukey). Right now our High Wood region is under attack. We could avoid that, couldnt we?
Comments
vt
nice article
peace with france was a double facepalm.
USA POLITIC SUX
Vote!
V!
vote vote vote
one big true
Hail EDEN!
Hail Spain!
Hail Croatia!
Hail Poland!
Hail Romania!
USA should out of EDEN \o/
This has gotten 400 votes and numerous rude comments in the Polish press. You know how rude it is to ask for help from your allies then insult them when they show up? This is classless...we are guests in Poland helping Poland out with their battle all the while people are telling us how much we suck and that we should leave EDEN.
Vote, btw. some say that USA didn't help while our NoB campain because they didn't want Poland to have high iron, we would be competition to USA then, i hope it's just a gossip ...
i want see answear for taht statement
@mikioli...we kami'd in NoB battle so we had nothing to give in the RW. Do a little reasearch before you throw your allies under the bus.
@Aaron S .. you could do drain attack on London as was planned ? it would give more than tanking in RW
hava a nice trip eUSA
but...
how long ?
😛
We kami'd too, Croatia kami'd too, Spain kami'd too and they fought kami again (starting day with ~60 well, 1 fight, hospital and another 5 fights)
All truth!I dont know why america is angry and want to leave,because of africa,oh c'mon!That would be EDEN first goal if Slovenia was gone!If Anyone want's to leave EDEN he is Failnix pupet,that is BIG tactical error,and if that hapend,USA will be guilty for eden doom,mark my words!We should stay together,and work together,and organise ourselfs better!
I agree with Martinoz... vote 🙂
1. Cash flow in and out of the CBO has not changed since Karnataka. Our budget has remained nearly the same since. Each new high resource region has a diminishing return. We also PAY for that region, unlike certain other occupiers.
3. Keep talking about Sindh. It hasn't been beaten to death and really helps the US's view of it's allies to keep trolling about it. /sarcasm
4. We entered the fray in France and opened up MPP's against ourselves to help wipe them from the map to help Spain because they lost their initiative. We marched to HLK and opened up a blocking attack against a massive fortress to regain ground in Romania. Yet our "allies" continue to question us when we don't bend over backwards and bend to their every whim.
It's a real shock why the US has lost faith in EDEN. Every loss is placed at our feet, and every time we don't cave our focus 100% our media is trolled by our so-called allies, despite other nations in EDEN consistently ignoring allied focus.
Keep it up, you only further the rift.
v
I'll tell to Martinoz why US signed a peace treaty because he is clearly speaking out of his a**.
USA should come to phoenix alliance
@PahorNimaPojma
No. USA should pursuit their own policy.
Of course. Pile it on, guys. This is exactly the stuff I need to come to a rational decision - NOT. Seriously, if you're interested in building ties to the US STOP TROLLING OUR MEDIA. End of story.
I endorse this article.
If you leave EDEN Americans what next?
Do you think Russians will help you? Or maybe Brazilians love you? I don't think so...
South Africa was tactical mistake. Even we conquer, still the government is Phoenix puppets. It was sensless.
But what if we fail to get more citizenship than Fenix. eSA always will be in danger. This country is cursed by blood diamonds🙁
Anyway this article is too much >.> Americans remember - this articles are personal opinion of people 😨 IMO It's just rude to point out every USA mistake now :d. I hope our relations will get better
The peace with France would have been great had Spain not been so determined to conquer a little extra territory. And as far as America kamikaze in NOB Aaron; get used to it, nothing the eUS ever does will ever be enough to inoculate it from criticism.
Sounds like our allies don't want our help at Rhone Alps? How many more trolling articles, from our own allies, will there be? It's really beginning to sound like our allies really want us to leave EDEN since they won't stop their complaining.
Don't take it personal Maxx Johnson
Josh Frost and his statement + his behaviour hurts Polish people and we think he is one big fail. He is the problem not USA
We should be partners not slaves
PS- Remember that usually there is 2 after 1 not 3 :>
Cool story US bro's. Cool move as well. Go follow Junior's trail. You two seem to be worthy of one another.
To all Americans.
Please note, that those articles condemn not you, but your current government and IT'S decisions. As for you, fellow Edenians from oversea, I have other two choice words 😉
Semper Fi!
>some say that USA didn't help while our NoB campain because they didn't want Poland to have high iron, we would be competition to USA then, i hope it's just a gossip ...
That's just stupid. If we didn't want competition, then we would take out Spain first.
THIS 63 DAYS OLD GUY IS RIGHT.
STUPID USA WANTING EQUAL TREATMENT AND RESPECT.
(Then wtf am I in Rhone Alps helping for?)
Seriously, if you are in the Polish military, shut up.
Stop complaining ...
Thanks for coming tonight.
I hope our relationship will be better.
WOW, This is exactly what EDEN needs right now, lets troll the US media even more. My dear god do you want another UK???
"Vote, btw. some say that USA didn't help while our NoB campain because they didn't want Poland to have high iron, we would be competition to USA then, i hope it's just a gossip ..."
Lets lay this fracking comment to rest now. I know who said that comment and it was an EDEN OFFICIAL (a member of HQ) who said that not a fracking US administration member. Their exact statement was "Are you guys sure you want to spend 30k gold, sacrifice High Iron to Serbia and risk the whole UK campaign (which btw the US did at POLANDS bequest with OUR MONEY) on this?" On an added note the regions the US gained "from" EDEN, it used only its gold for 90% of the attacks, war decs and tanking. In comparison the US spent between 5-7k gold on Saarland, NoB and the NoB RW for Poland. Wow we are such shitty allies. I forgot the time we deployed for 12 days to Spain/Poland to close Germany and France. Please try to play the "who messed up or is a worse ally" anecdote game with me. I am holding lots of countries dirty secrets and I will be happy to let them out.
@Gaius ok, everybody makes mistakes, but why everybody blame USA?
Because nobody else doing things so stupid like your action in Sindh.
It amazes me how eR is so similar to real life, if you dont kiss the US's ass they make a fuss about being ignored. Get a grip.
I read the article and couldn't help but wonder what it was meant to accomplish. How does the author of this article hope it will impact the future?
What's the motivation - did the author write the article with the goal of strengthening EDEN? Encouraging the dissolution of EDEN? Just trolling for the lulz? Perhaps the author felt butthurt and thought a nice rant would help, or it could be they just wanted to get in on the current media circus while it lasts.
The article doesn't seem like a very positive contribution IMO.
Frankly, I think it sucks.
@mikioli - I fought more than you did in NoB, so perhaps you should look at facts before you talk.
Me? 18 fights http://ereptools.net/battles/playerFights/id/1527273" target="_blank">http://ereptools.net/battles/playerFight[..]7273
You? 5 fights http://ereptools.net/battles/playerFights/id/1424157" target="_blank">http://ereptools.net/battles/playerFight[..]4157
scroll down to battle 9059
and oh look I fought in Prekmurje too, and yet I get daily insults for fighting exactly where you wanted me to fight. How long would you put up with a friend yelling and insulting you for doing the VERY THING THEY WANTED YOU TO DO IN THE FIRST PLACE????????????
Gaius Julius You seem to do not remember USA freedom fight, Maintoba battle and much more. We always stand behind You but You don't do the same acording Us. Everyone makes mistakes, but not so STUPID like this one in SINDH. That was just IDIOTIC and people who gave this order should be banned in your policy. However i would not be amazed if it was Your idea.
Bless Ya
John we do not blame americans but Your Government!
Excellent rebuttal Gaius. They wanna throw stuff in our face, I say we throw some of our own dirt. I have read ONE TOO MANY of these trolling articles. I'm tired of hearing that we'll fail without EDEN. You know what the funny thing is? Spain, Poland or anyone in EDEN can't do ANYTHING without EDEN. Even Phoenix can't fight alone. That's the nature of things, so this is a stupid argument. I'm tired of these articles. No resolution. I say screw the situation and screw EDEN!
USA SHOULD OUT OF EDEN. I'd rather have a tough time on my own then "help" from "allies" like you.
Lame story bro.
@Pabloo: You really have no idea what you are talking about do you? When the US fought BOTH days in Saarland who do you think ordered that. When someone figured out how to swap around the French blocks and what not who do you think did that? I can list times that certain countries leaders (President and others) SLEPT through a planned battle start at 23:30 and kept up 1500 EDEN SOLDIERS. BTW did you even look at my citizenship, I'm not from the US dipshit.
This article accomplishes nothing. If you are not in the EDEN High Command or a leader of a EDEN member country, your article is all but useless in relation to this diplomatic mess.
People are whiny.
Knock it off with the Sindh crap. We made a mistake. We publicly apologized for it. So shut up!
ePoland = classless piece-O-poo!