Condemnation of the Spanish Aggression
HuCard
My feelings when I get home today to see Spain attacking France were a mixture of unpleasant surprise, disappointment, and a bit of anger. This assault cannot be described as anything but downright foolish in every regard.
For once, the attack is completely unjustified. Even if Spain holds an understandable grudge against France since her occupation by her in World War III, France has behaved very well in the time since the cessation of hostilities. She did not actively partake in any of the later attacks by PEACE GC and later ex-PEACE states, successfully sought reconciliation with the USA and Canada, and supported Malaysia against Indonesia, which back then was still part of her own alliance. To strike such a re-established nation having show goodwill and renewed trustworthiness completely out of the blue and without any preceding provocation is simply a wholly erroneous move and one which ought to be globally condemned.
But not only does this war hurt Spain's image and of course France herself, it will also be a nasty stain on alliance politics. For once, EDEN has lost its innocence. While there have already been a few rather questionable moves such as a few EDEN states PTOing other ones or Poland half-heartedly attacking Lithuania, none of them has been this blatantly ill-spirited as this one, which will taint the entire alliance's image.
On the other hand, after the departure of its most aggressive and imperialist states such as Hungary or Iran, the small rest of PEACE GC has ceased to be a threat. It became an alliance of smaller, and with the exception of the United Kingdom overall more or less agreeable countries with whom it might have been worth negotiating to finally come to a peaceful solution and to cease inter-alliance hostilities. Having one of our members this unjustly attack one of theirs will undoubtedly ruin any process we have made or would have been able to make in the future.
Lastly, France, in her search of strong allies, might fall back into the sphere of influence of PEACE GC's old war machines such as Hungary or Serbia, which would merely strengthen these unholy bonds again after they had been decaying for a good while now and in the worst case eventually lead to the rise of a new warmongering alliance.
As the ever-just mediator, I think it is Canada's duty to try and restrain the damage of Spain's stupidity. I'm well aware that they're our allies who need to be cared for, and I am not ignorant enough to suggest an expedition of the CAF on France's side knowing how poisonous this would be for our relations to Spain and EDEN as a whole, but I demand that we as a nation vocally condemn this nonsensical and in every way destructive aggression and that we aid France in other ways (economic and rhetorical) as well as we can; for the sake of a nation which has shown to be able to better its ways, one we share a language with, and one who which finds itself in undeserved peril!
Comments
Excellent analysis! Good read!
I'd like to point out something, and this is the Foreign Relation Department Response.
Spain is one of our best ally, as they have done so much in the past for us, France well they invaded us. let's not lose focus here. If Spain want to have it's fun than it's their business not ours. We will not interfere in this matter.
Spain is like a wave upon the shores of France. Attacking, then receding, attacking again, and then receding.
If they were attempting a serious invasion, there were better ways to do it. They clearly are not, I just hope they're okay with the MPPs they've activated and the problems that entails.
i think spain has good reason to attack france. To many the france-spain relationship is not unlike our relationship with the e-UK. That said i agree jacobi it was silly to activate those mpps
It is an excellent analysis - you will rise far HuCard - the force is strong in you!
For good reason I will not comment yet on this situation except to say that Indos and Huns are in Spain and attack on eItaly will meet with CAF.
Spain has a feud that must be respected. Also this game could get more fun.
''For once, EDEN has lost its innocence.''
Because the PTO on the United Netherlands was quite innocent right? They have 2 regions for already a month and EDEN doesnt care.
Voted!
Well at least they are making the game fun and ensuring that their people don't become just a collection of 2 clickers.
A well written article.
My superiors in MoFA have already given the offical stance and I am not briefed on our Spanish relations. That being said I agree that Spain certainly has an emotional right to attack, but it still probably isn't wise.
I think Canada has a role as a peace-keeper and while we must stand by our allies, we do not have to approve of their actions. I personally feel that the CAF should stay out of this all together, only getting involved if Spain's sovereign territory is threatened, and even then only defensively.
Thanks for the analysis HuCard!
Interesting...
Call me crazy ... but PEACE is splintering … now seems like the time to lay the smackdown and aquire ourselves some much needed resources. It’s eRepublik, not the real world, we don’t need to be seen as “peacekeepers” anymore. Why not go on the offensive for a change. We talked about this before, it’s this need for “diplomacy” that’s getting us stuck in the mire. eSpain is out there doing something now that there is a widow of opportunity.
I don’t want to just sit and wait for eHungary to build up it’s strength again for the next round … the best defense is a good offense, and I say we move forward.
Amen Velvet. Echoes my sentiments exactly.
It's a game. We have a chance to legitimately return the favour from when those bastards took our country from us. Let's send some damage back. I'm not saying in this particular battle, but with our own movements to secure regions of value.
If sometimes Spains looks as this article makes looks Canada I keep out the game.
I neither praise nor condemn Spain's aggression
Nevertheless I applaud them for breathing some life into THE GAME
"lulz" lands you where eUK is now, nuff said.
SaraD, only if you don't think about your actions first. 😉
That said, the only way to keep the 'two clickers' interested and active, is to have some form of war for them. Would you not agree? Point in case, Hungary. Probably the most active two-clickers in the game. Why? Constant war/battles to keep them occupied. Not everyone has the time or drive to get into the political side of things, so they need a stimulant from somewhere else in the game... war!
Diplomacy becomes extremely difficult when governments change every month.
They invaded us (thanks to their MPP'S), they'll pay for it! It's a question of honour not of wisdom or politics.
+ It makes the game funnier!!! Come and help us they invaded you too
Amen Rylde. Settling for being a peace abiding country, got us wiped off the map. Now people want to HELP France? Ha!
You know this country has problems when the smallest politcal slight is remembered and never forgotten.
But when it comes to those that helped wipe us off the map we have all these hippies rushing to forgive them and demoning those that actually want some revenge.
In the End War and revenge are more fun.
spain did not appease france (our former invader), unlike ourselves who signed that shameful peace agreement with them.
I say "GO Spain, kill froggy"
yup big suprise. EDEN the purely defensive alliance going on the offense..
HMMMM.. where have i heard that before????
maybe we should stop trying to ride around on our high moral horses and remember that this is a video game and no real people or infrastructure are being damaged (though sometimes i wonder if thats how RL government see's their job 😛)
people are bored. they want to fight somebody.
You sound as though I wasn't treating this like a game and enjoying it.
I got to go with the Spaniards on this one,
France minced around in the background taking glory from their former allies strength, a little slap won't do them any harm.
http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/hg-what-the-hell--1067440/1/20" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/hg-w[..]1/20
Response to HuCard's article.
An embattled people are an active people.
In this game, war is the best possible thing to happen to a country.
Problem is, 95% of people think that peace in eRepublik is akin to peace in rl.
It's not.
We eCanadians need to get what Romainia, Hungary and Indonesia got months ago.
The Only way to be a Superpower is to be on the offensive, the only way to show the eWorld that we are strong, are to be the ones on the offensive.
For to long has EDEN been that has Everthing to lose, and nothing to gain.
I am Disgusted by wars fought simplly to gain back what you had before.
This doesnt mean I wish for EDEN to occupy Spain forever, but what I wish for at least is the message conveyed that we are not afraid to fight.
GO SPAIN, HAIL EDEN
Tactically, it was a silly and stupid move for eSpain. However, eFrance is far from the innocent player as many point them out to be. People say "but we attacked them first in 2008" and that we did, but we didn't conquer their entire country now did we? Had it stopped at the maritime provinces, I'd be more willing to leave things be... but it didn't stop there now did it. I do fully intend to help out eSpain in any way possible through this expedition into eFrance.
Once a GC scum always a GC scum. France deserves it.
HuCard, I'm entirely of your opinion.
"We eCanadians need to get what Romainia, Hungary and Indonesia got months ago."
Pet countries?
Liberté, égalité, fraternité...
ce sont des valeurs qui se perdent...