[World War Bug] Battle of Indiana
Zoli
..................
Update - Official response came from Admins. It was a display bug
..........
Another bug, what a surprise!
The USA attacked Indiana, Russia at 23:11. See it here: USA - Russia war
But the USA was blocked by Columbia in New Mexico. The USA retreated from there but it reatreated at 23:15. See it here:
See finished battles in Columbia - USA war
So the USA attacked a region of Russia while being blocked. The USA attacked 4 minutes earlier than the blocking battle was over. Looking at latest international events you can see it that the USA attacked before retreating from the other battle!
I think the battle of Indiana must be closed. I have addressed this request submitting a ticket and with an open letter too. This article is intended only to show others this bug.
P.S. Even if we do not agree on the type of the bug, I am glad that we all agree that this is a bug \o/
Comments
But I fought there already x.x
Dont waste Panda's fight!
NO.What about the bug with portugal?Che sera sera.
It's just a display bug 🙂
Do you think that Emerick would have retread from New Mexico if he already could have attacked Russia ? 🙂
vladb - it is not a display bug. It shows the exact time!
Zoli if it weren't a display bug we would've attacked a lot more than just one state (and sooner).
Well if Emerick had the chance to not have to retreat : P. Display bugs happen, but its good to point them out. But is it that necessary, we retreated the battle so this would have happened anyway. So arnt you basically arguing that 4 minutes be dropped off the battle for indiana.
@Publius - up to now decesion where taken based on the time shown in game. So if they stick to this then the battle of Indiana should be closed.
I've been noticing lately a lot of finished battles being posted a couple minutes after they finish
OFF
Ha orgot akarok csinálni kell új emailcím?
Elkezdtem regelni és :
"Your email address is already in our database. "
Persze, mivel a kari is azzal van fennt...
Yes, it is nothing but a display bug.
Everyone saw a case like that at least one time (a battle displayed over after a couple of minutes after another one has started).
Lame "propaganda", Zoli. You should chose to report real problems instead something anyone knows is not a problem. 😉
Pathetic - at least find a true bug. That shouldn't be too hard 😉
Zoli ..then why would Emerick retreat after ?
I do not think that Emerick even tried to attack Russia without retreating from New Mexico first ,he is not a noob .
Imagine you login into ER and you see Columbia attacking you and you want to attack Russia ..what do you do
a)Retreat from the columbian war and then attack Russia
b)Attack Russia even though you know it's not possible 🙂
Assuming that b is the option you would take after that you would just retreat from New Mexico because ? ..
a)you are good friend with Admins and you do not want Zoli to open an open letter 🙂--does not care
b)Peace will start invading top 5 article with complaints -more fun 🙂
c)because you can -not as fun as a or b 🙂
I would stick with 1A and a display bug 🙂
Hi Zoli! 🙂
Off
Dengezik: igen, új email cím kell, más, mint ami a karakterednek van.
@Zoli
We also wanted MO+KS fixed (http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/what-just-happened--913678/1/20).
The in-game result is the same, this article is just trying to work over the admins for a display bug.
It is a display bug.
I remember Han Solo and a big part of the Romanian community screaming their lungs out when this happened in a block from Pakistan against Indonesia 🙂
Display bug. Geesh Zoli you can do better than that. Normally your arguments are good. Did your little vaction take the edge off?
its a display bug, get over yourself.
Tell Russia thanks for visiting 🙂 and Colombia that we'll see them very soon in Bogota!
Display bug.
lamest propaganda article ever, c'mon, zoli you can do better
Display bug. Zoli learn the game mechanics
it's a display bug..
T-0 when u push the retreat button ->retreat in the war engine
T-x when the battle closes ->shown on news page
T-4 in our case
No bug, USA retreated exactlly at the right time,
Nice try, Zoli. The attack button does not appear if you are blocked. And the move Emerick made was perfectly legal under the game rules - less than six hours = ok to retreat, and he still had initiative against Russia. Oops. Colombia is free to attack, as it still has initiative against the US.
You all admit it is a bug, so it must be corrected
yes, the display should be corrected 😉
I'd hope the avatar bug gets fixed first. :/
vote+signed
You're off your game, man.
I think you are complaining just to complain. My daughter does that. She's 4 months old
it is not a bug.
zoli - you know that after a retreat it takes 4 minutes until the region is pass to the new owner.
but the atack start instantly.
so that the retreat is latest than the atack.
i am surprise that you dont know that.
it hapens so many time until now
si ce sa faca Zoli ca sa nu ramana mai prejos cand a vazut ca n-are dreptate, o baga pe aia cu : "You all admit it is a bug, so it must be corrected" 😃
Man, slow news day in Zoliland? Srsly. If there is a bug that makes the timestamp 4 minutes off that's like the least interesting bug since I joined. If you need ideas for articles just say so.
admins can do someting only if 13 mpp's are activated ,,, 🙁
NO BUG
US retreat at 00.00.00 (h/m/s)from region X
US atack at 00.00.01 region Y
The retreat takes 4 minutes until the region change the owner (the mesage is something like: Ocupation is iminent...)
So. In latest will be apear like that
00.00.01 US atack region Y
00.04.00 US lost region X
When romania was on road to kartanak we retreat from a region where we losing before the battle end in a region were we winning. but becouse the 4 minuntes the retreat end after the battle were we win and for that we dont manage to take the initiative
i'm pretty sure it just took time for the battle to show up as retreated. during the 5 minute lapse, the battle was closed, and said something about the region being overrun and the president of US had retreated, though there was no "taken by columbia" flag, gold collected, etc.
All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others
flik is right : there are some transactions running on the database ,the DB needs to be updated ..when the update is finished the message is displayed .
It just takes loger to update the data when a battle is finished then when a new battle starts .
And it is not a bug 🙂..you cannot display the message when the action begins ..you display the message when the action is finished 🙂
That was the problem with the retreat button ..people where pushing the button but not getting the new actions available to them instantly .Better a message displayed later then not having the attack button ..Don't you think? 🙂
funny how lvl 15 noobs brag with their knowledge.. must be genetic...
flik has a point, altho we can't know what happens just trust that the admins are fair and impartial 🙂
Ysuol - talk less, search more
for you and for zoli
http://www.erepublik.com/en/wars/show/504" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/wars/show/50[..]/504
Shanxi ended on 03 May 2009, 09:20
Indonesia has conquered this region
Sindh ended on 03 May 2009, 09:16
Romania has secured this region
lock at the time
http://www.erepublik.com/en/battles/show/6424" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/battles/show[..]6424
Shanxi has been occupied by Indonesia.
Indonesia obtained 0.96 GOLD from Romania
The President of Romania has retreated from the battlefield.
http://www.erepublik.com/en/battles/show/6418" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/battles/show[..]6418
Sindh has been secured by Romania
So at that time the president of romania retreat from Shanxi just before the and of Sindh but because those 4 minutes the retreat finished after 4 minutes and we lost the chance to take initiative.
What surprised me is that zoli not knows this situation.
i think that he is awere about this but he is in a black week.
words no longer came from his had but from heart.
and right know his heart is full of anger, pain, sorrow.
Battles show different times in international threads and country threads too....i guess they should all be closed as well
No,this is not Zoli.Somebody stole his password!!😃
Ysuol cand vezi ca nu poti contracara subiectul ,incepi sa ataci in dreapta si-n stanga fara logica . frumos gest , numai un anumit gen de oameni se comporta asha si sti si tu care 🙂
felicitari pt noul "tag".
lol. lassan frissít ennyi
Where is kovaskhoko?
eh...let me introduce you the game mechanics, Zoli..
Each region after conquered takes exactly 5 minutes to appear in the latest events and the swapping of territory executes.
So if it writes retreat at 23:15 it happened at 23:10 in fact.
The region was under "transfer" as I wrote above: it takes 5 minutes every time but it was no more under attack so USA was free to attack.
Lets say there is a bug and it isn't that the timestamp is off. 4 mins wouldn't change the outcome of this battle. QQ it's over for peace.
Zoli the Trollie clinging desperately to any hope he can 😉 This is fun
Maybe we should stop calling him Zoli and start calling him Loli. I lolled before I was even done reading this. XD
Hey
Fight in Illinois
To who wrotte the article... is not Columbia, is C O lombia