[FT] Rebuilding Our Broken Community
AugustusV
Day 1,153 | January 16th, 2011
[FT] Issue #6 | Rebuilding Our Broken Community
Constant problem's plague eCanada. Corruption, greed, lies, and division are some of the many that are literally threatening to tear the country apart, especially when certain individuals run off with almost the entire treasury. This is a problem which is hurting our nation far more than any well-planned enemy invasion could. Why? Because we are destroying our community, and if this game stands for nothing else, it stands for the friendships formed and the team spirit that we should theoretically encourage and have. Please note that Alliances have risen and fallen based on how close or fractured the community within it was.
Our problems are much deeper than the superficial conclusion that "we have crooks in the system"; the problem pertains to the much deeper issue of how we deal with each other.
On the issue of psychology, Rigour6 in a new article has again used his pragmatic approach to set some clear clues, warnings, and downright in-your-face conclusions on why we are failing as a community.
Let us note that most recently we have given rise to a new concern, that of corruption within the Canadian Armed Forces, and of how some of our most dedicated and trusted players such as Coda may have engaged in some immoral behavior. In this flurry of opinionated articles each trying to shed a new light on the situation, I would like to try and keep perspective, and offer my bluntly honest opinion.
Max Maher has had a legitimate concern here. He was tipped off that there could be corruption in the CAF and was given some solid proof. Why do we all despise him and call him a traitor? Why do we treat those who care or who have the courage to care with such disgust?
Let's keep it clear fellas, no matter who gave this information, and no matter if you are CAF or not, or if you like Max Maher or not, facts are facts. We are so used to putting emotion in front of ration that we immediately cling to other issues such as "well Rolo Tahamsee gave us the information and don't like him cause whose he to talk about corruption, so we don't even want to look at the proof", or "Coda would never do this guys". Anyone remember 1ronman? One of our most trusted players who ended up being one of our most rotten? Yeah... "he'd never do it", Deja Vu. I'm not saying Coda is a crook like 1ronman, but it's time we stop blindly trusting people.
The point is Max Maher is not a traitor. Give the man a break and respect the fact that he knows very well how many people will start hating him for opening the subject, he knows he may become a unpopular fellow, but yet he choose to do the right thing. I find that highly respectable.
The problem is some if not most of us only think of our friends, of our political, military, and social goals, and try to frame our behavior around that.
If you look around we are currently full of "trolling", which by definition defies logic. Trolling is the "art" of arguing for the sake of arguing, and for causing someone else anger and grief and somehow taking a sick pleasure it in all. We have people who never take anything seriously because "they're just too good for that", frankly I find that to be a fear of becoming vulnerable to criticism but nevertheless we are becoming a society of "too cool for school" trolls.
Also please note humor is amazing. It keeps stuff fun and us laughing. But trolling is not the type of humor we need. "TemujinBC iz a butt" is harmless fun, "TemujinBC you're stupid irl and and anarchy sucks" is destructive trolling. Sometimes trolling can be funny to some, but it hurts our society and creates division regardless. Teasing can indeed be funny, but teasing has never led to anything good and only enforces the bad character of someone who props his own broken self-esteem at the expense of others. Bottom point, teasing leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to moar suffering. Someone trolled will troll back and may even develop a habit which further hurts society.
I myself have went against former friends like TCO, TemujinBC, Acacia Mason, I have went against possible political strategic organizations for my career such as the DAL, CPF, etc, I am now even going against the CAF and Coda, whom I still respect. I do it because when I see unfairness, when I see bullshit, when I see people acting in ways I think is wrong I can't help but act on principle and refuse to stay quiet. People constantly hate on me for that, and most oftentimes it's very much personal, because I have either directly or indirectly interfered with their selfish objectives or because they think I have something personal against them. It's the common defensive mentality that we need to rid ourselves of.
Another problem we have: making everything personal and bringing RL into arguments.
Have you fellas heard of Lavis Knight? This guy is the definition of a player who sticks by principle. He plays the game for some mental stimulation and for connecting in a friendly manner with the community. He quits every organization and refuses to deal with people who do what he finds is immoral. He has quit the CAF because of this recent issue, even though he got free supplies when he was in there. This guy represent what we all should strive to become. A friendly community based on principle and on enjoying this game for it's more interesting aspects, not just the infantile and pathetic trolling.
Regarding Coda, my opinion is that she clearly didn't think it was "ok" what she was about to do, and Kronos Q also said it didn't seem right, and if she wanted to do the right thing Coda would have approached congress honestly and told them the situation. I'm sure we'd all let her do what she wanted to do if it made sense. I don't understand why people don't just apologize and move on, and why we need to get so defensive and fracture our society into groups who support Coda, and those who do not. Even if we do agree or disagree, why must there be so much disrespect and not why instead have an open discussion where potential friends an allies can agree to disagree and/or make their points better understood without raging like little monkeys?
The greater issue I was trying to explain with eCanada is that we have created a destructive culture that cannot breed anything but more problems. And put on trial as many individuals as you like, this won't end until we change our mentality. It's true not everyone will change at once, but if enough of us take the torch maybe others will follow. Why can't we just all sit around and smoke a nice spiff?
We continually fracture our community. We do not work on principle but rather we work based on our selfish goals and wonder why we breed corruption. We cannot build a community by hiding the truth, we build a community by rallying around a common principle. We must rally around a common value, not a person or group, for all said parties could easily turn the wrong way.
For those who have seen the movie "pay it forward" (Google it if you didn't), our community works the same. What makes all the difference is in what we choose to pay forward. What will YOU pay forward?
-
Octavian_F is the CEO of the Investment Bank CIBC, eCanadian congressman, and Chief Editor of the Financial Times.
Comments
Pay it forward! \o/
United (in values) we stand. o7
good article
basically, the way I see it, is like this:
donations are perfectly legal by game mechanics
if you accept that, good for you
If you don't, then you need to realise that you can't have your cake and eat it, too
either everyone that gets an in-game donation is innocent,
or
everyone that gets an in-game donation is "guilty" by some subjective standard.
We want to be a team?
Then we better friggin decide which is which.
We can't have it both ways
😁Pakistani nationals living in Finland are part of my TEAM! That's how multi-cultural and inclusive eCanada is.
A thoughtful message, Octavian. If only more people would turn over a new leaf, as you have done, and actively foster team spirit and non-divisive gameplay.
voted.
i cant believe i am saying this 😛
I agree with octavian ; )
Quality article as always.
you can have cake and eat it too, i'm doing so right now!
also, voted
voted
Groovy
May I ask you a question, You are talking about corruption in the HC, Wich is basicly Coda receiving funds to defend Canada. That is one hell of a corruption!
But I keep hearing the word, Corruption in the High command like if everyone in there was taking something in the cookie jar. But is there a single other example of HC getting more fund? I would like to see that, Because except accusation, I have yet to see just one single example of another HC member getting more than his share of supply.
So please, let's stop generalisation. It's really annoying.
I can't say I've generally agreed with you on many things in the past Oct_F, but with this article I can't help but agree 100% with what you're saying here.
The corruption goes higher than HC Chucky.
OF is talking about a corrosive culture that damages all parts of eCanada.
CAF just happens to be the flavour of the day.
Except alot of gold was donated from private people and organizations to TemujinBC to use how he saw fit, he saw fit to use it on Coda.
I cant speak to any of the screenshots taken in HC though.
Do you mean broken system?
The community is the people that inhabit the system. Transplant someone from their RL and put them on an island and they will backstab and lies to one and other because that is the game.
If you think Coda and HC have their unethical hand in the cookie jar, you should see what those Swedish and American tanks received during Ontario, Quebec, and the Nfld RW.
PimpDollaz - Not all donations are the same. Intent matters, whether you want to accept it or not.
nice article. Two thoughts.
Choice of language affects relationships. I.E. "corruption" is consistently chosen instead of "error". It inflames.
The disfunction may not be as widespread as suspected. The number of players who compete for positions of influence is small. One of the tools to increase influence is language.
Good article, clear and to the point.
Golden. Keep the good stuff coming.
First time i read an article this long.
I actually proposed amending the Cap Fund Act in order to limit the money tanks received. However it was outdated and the proposed Cap of funds had an increase.
Besides trying to propose to limit this Cap on funds, i also proposed to divert as much gold as it is possible to CAF soldiers training with Napoleon. This way we create more tanks, and all the money for a battle is distributed among more tanks.
People needs to understand differences between trolling vs. constructive criticism.
o7
Nice article, Octo_F.
Very good article. Voted. 🙂
Me being a normal player who is new to this game, this is a bunch of BS. All of you posts articles on what is wrong and then NEVER do anything about it! The problem is you people.
Well you being a new player are not yet aware of the fine details of this community. In time you will learn and understand the situation.
However this article is very much an indication of not just what is wrong, but how to change for the better.
Spend some more time here and you'll understand what I mean.
I don't know how long I can last, mainly because of the greed and corruption that controls the people in power. You may WANT to help people like me out and I commend you for that, but it just isn't working and hasn't worked since I started playing this game.
This game is by default, a democracy.
Democracy entails a certain level of responsibility. So if things have not worked out for the better, we are to blame.
Pointing fingers always helps, but we elected our failed leaders.
A change in mentality is needed. Change that, and you'll get the leaders you deserve. Same goes for real life; ignorance breeds corruption.
Perhaps the problem here is that many of our "older" and "trusted" players can't be trusted anymore.. maybe we as an country need to bring in fresh players, fresh thoughts and stop playing so much emphasis on how long people have been playing when we choose our elected officials and military commanders.
^ Exactly. Well said.
@Soulscode I agree 100%. Finally I have come across someone who understands and shares the same ideas as me. Thank God!!!!!! There is hope in this game hahaha
Bought votes are bought? But good article is good..
This is the reason why I quit eCanada with many of my friends and the 10 person I got in. Lies, greed, corruption, instability and much more... This is how we welcome new citizens? To every new peps outthere looking to help a communauty that really needed it, theres a couple of new countries that opened lately. Just go help em!
Sorry for my poor english. (JUST TRY to handle 2 languague perfectly..)
New Zeland or Denmark or Švicerland are 3 country that actually could use some new citizens.
"People needs to understand differences between trolling vs. constructive criticism"
and then stop trolling.
Stop trolling? On the internetz? Gasp! You speak blasphemy!
well this is interesting, i find this article to be quite reasonable and its premise legitimate.
but its from octavian, who helped exacerbate many of the problems outlined above....
this confuses me
Scorpius, turning over a new leaf in the middle of a sh*tstorm means you never know what side is going to land up.
Scorp apart from you being ironic which I'm not looking to argue with you about, I really don't appreciate your inability to make any sort of positive comment without negative one attached.
Plugson's right.
Damn, that was touching. If only I had a heart.
voted
@ Temu, a game is just a game. It is not RL, whether you all want to believe it or not
Actually a very good post by Octavian. He makes a lot of sense. Well written & voted.
Citizen B
i like the new Octavian_F better.......great article
voted and look who is here again! Citizen B
again the only reason why anyone is upset about any of this is because they want theirs LOL thats the simple reason why anyone cares ita a game , and a poorly managed and administrated game at that .
if everyone got some of the spoils then no one would care , its all about greed and has nothing to do with honesty of fair play in my eyes
but your article is great and i like you HA HA HA
stfu Wes! you are a thief, so that make you an asshole... Stop posting on everything every times. No one cares about thiefs and scumbags.
The corruption you speak of is no where near as rampany as your post makes it seem to be. There are a few bad apples, and unfortunatly in a system such as this when said bad apples have access they are able to do some severe damage, which makes the problem look far worse than it actually is.
Should we do something about that corruption, yes, most definatly. Leading a pogrom against everyone in government is not the way to do it though. I am not saying you are advising such, just stating this as a general statement.
This community suffered after the theft by Rolo, and unfortunatly it never learned the neccesity to remove the scum at that point. I hope this time things go differently.
😁 "Perhaps the problem here is that many of our "older" and "trusted" players can't be trusted anymore.. maybe we as an country need to bring in fresh players, fresh thoughts and stop playing so much emphasis on how long people have been playing when we choose our elected officials and military commanders." - Countries money spent on tanks makes newbies situation even worse (v & s).