CLM Volume 3: Freedom isn't Free
TemujinBC
There's an old bromide which I hear from time to time about how freedom isn't free. This article is going to explore that notion, and seek to clarify my stand on self-defense and who should bear the cost.
Since I am not quite two weeks into my citizenship in eRep, many important historical events have taken place which I have little or no knowledge of. This includes the complete removal of Canada, the exile (and return) of many of my fellow countrymen, and the alliances forged in dark and troubling times. I'm pleased that I was able to begin my citizenship in Canada. Had I joined eRep a mere couple of weeks prior to when I did, I may not have been so fortunate. In volume two of CLM, I was blasted in the comment section by Rylde for my desire to have the private sector handle the building of hospitals. I took it as a clear sign that he felt I was uneducated about the how taxes and the state were required in order that I might have the luxuries of today. It also seemed to me that he believes a centralized bureacracy is needed in order for things to work properly. An excerpt of his comment, and you can decide for yourself:
Alberta has a hospital only because it was donated to us from Sweden. Our
country is just recovering from being wiped out and citizens are already
clamoring for infrastructure. Sorry won't be much of that Till we and the USA
have our countries back. Wars cost money. Better move your ass to Alberta.
the govt knows this so thats why they want everyone there. Your taxes are
going to the war effort get used to that for awhile. Those blocks we do aren't
free.
While it is true our hospital was a gift from Sweden, that does not mean a group of enterprising business people could not have pooled resources to build one if given the chance. Currently the people are given no opportunity to build a hospital without the consent of the state. That is wrong, wrong, wrong on every level.
I am fully aware that wars cost money, and that in order for Canada to be whole again, it is going to cost a staggering amount. But the citizens of this country are already forming private army units. There is no reason to believe that Canada needs the State to protect us. Private citizens could organize more efficiently and more effectively if they were simply able to do so. Maintaining and defending our freedom may not be free, but surely the costs taken by the middleman (government) could be put to better use!
In a free society, the costs of defending borders and liberating regions would fall on those who desire the service (this does not rule out the possibility of charity). Rational self-interest would guide people, and they would voluntarily enter into agreements for mutual benefit. This is the most fair and most free way to do anything (whether it is running a business, building a home, eating at a restaurant, etc. In this way, no one is forced to fund the actions of another. No one has to pay for something they do not derive benefit from.
Currently, businesses pay a large amount to the state via taxes. This removes wealth that could be used to develop the business, increase wages for employees, advertise, and a multitude of other things. It also leaves less money that business has to donate to charitable causes (in a free society, one such cause could self-defense). The amount of taxes stolen by our government from businesses must be astounding. I think we can all agree with the statement that "freedom isn't free". It is my hope that one day we will all come to realize that Statism costs so much more.
Thank you all for reading Canadian Liberty Magazine, and a special thanks to Rylde for his candid comments.
Comments
Once Canada is fully free the second Q5 hospital will be implemented 🙂
TP, Shouldn't you be in university studyin' or something? 🙂
If I were a more experienced player with a larger supply of wealth, I would build a hospital in every province. And charge a fortune for people to see a doctor!
Good rebuttal, temujin. I'm still not completely with you, but you make some excellent points.
Thanks George.
I subscribe to you for a reason
TemujinBC lol yeah SFU is killing, just taking a break
Haha im planning to do that. Buying a Q5 hospital for BC out of my own gold. I'm 1/5 there? It shall be named BC St. Panda Hospital
Sweet, on both things (SFU and the hospital)
Heh, I hope it's a good reason, Jacobi :-0
http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/-privatized-healthcare-in-canada--932466/1/20" target="_blank">http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/-pri[..]1/20
My Response😁^
would it be cool if the admins instituted private health care? sure, that would be neat. then somebody REALLY rich could save up tons of money, build their own hospital and then charge for health.
oh wait... you can already do that with gifts..
that doesnt mean i didnt enjoy reading your well written article.
I just dont see how it would fit into the game.
IE from a businessmans perspective (i infact own my own company IRL) where would you be getting your income stream from after you build this hospital.
i mean why would i pay say $1 each day to heal after i've fought if i can just pay $9 to fly to alberta and never pay again.
do you see what i mean?
I'm very curious to see how your idea flesh's out in a more detailed business plan.
I hate the smell of neoconservatism in the morning.
TemujinBC, I have to say I think you're ignoring the very real consequence of defence and health being public goods. There is no compelling rational self interest for any individual and/or business in this game to put their own money into building a hospital, as screamingslave pointed out, there's no charge to use a hospital (and therefore no potential for earnings or profit), even our enemies could land in our territory and use our hospitals, this is a textbook definition of the freeloader effect.
More than that, although fighting a battle is a personal decision, without government direction and effort exactly what kind of national defence can we realistically mount using only self-interested people acting in their own interests, diminishing the greater national interest? Again, freeloader effect, why would anyone voluntarily expend effort and resource when they're better off freeloading?
I tend to agree with Dr. Pain, this is far more ideological than rational argument, and I'm afraid I completely disagree with your assertions. Government management of hospitals is inevitable, and government management of the war effort is essential, even with NGOs fighting alongside the army. Unless you intend to fundraise your way to affording a hospital, or an army, which is a noble and worthwhile effort, I would suggest you consider that it's not rational self-interest that will win the day, rather charity and patriotism that will define the generosity that will fund or enlist recruits for such endeavours. Individual self-interest is all well and good in business, but not when the national/societal needs of the public interest are at play.
Cheers,
AR1ARX
Well, first, the state isn't getting that much in taxes, and second, most of that goes to defense, to allow citizens to have a say in their government at all.
Third, I agree that one hospital isn't enough. I'd like to see several more. That would allow our workers to work more efficiently and yield economic benefits to individuals, employers, and the government. Other successful economies in Europe do this already. Leaving health care only to the healthy is economically counterproductive, just as in RL.
Fourth, if you want private health care in the game, there's nothing stopping you from setting up an organization and giving gifts to people for cash.
Sadly, it seems that the vast majority of citizens in this game simply don't get it. I'm with you, TemujinBC, all the way. Except for the part about freedom "not being free." I still can't get my head around that (aren't individuals free by nature?). Of course individual effort and self-interest are sufficient to meet a military or a medical need. Not to stab at a straw man or anything, but the idea that order in society would collapse without someone to forcefully harness our productive energies is utter folly. I would likely exceed my character limit in going into specifics, so I will have to leave this comment woefully undeveloped for now. Keep the fight going, TemujinBc.