Join the new world

HALLO EINDONESIA


ENGLISH VERSION

The title is clear. Let us discuss.


"The meaning of the word to steal yourself in KBBI is: take someone else's property
without permission or illegally, usually secretly. Or in English the meaning of thief is: "one that steals especially stealthily or secretly also: one who commits theft or larceny". Steal itself means: "take (another person's property) without permission or legal right and without intending to return it"

From the meaning of the word clearly must "belong to someone else", the problem is the SH medal is given after the war is over. So how can this SH hunter be claimed to steal if it doesn't belong to anyone? Then from the meaning of the word also mentioned "furtively". This is the online world, what's hidden in hiding? Everything can be seen 24 hours, so there is no stealth. "

Right. One nitpick: the definition of "stealth" should be dropped. Grabbing people's motorbikes is also called theft, right? BM 2808 AE nostalgia intensifies

The questions that arise from this definition of "theft as taking someone else's property" are:
Is this legal? Clear.
Is this halal? Let us discuss.

Because SH hasn't owned anyone in the span of 2 hours, then theft should not be relevant! Auctions are even more relevant.

Information regarding the auction ...
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/7294/does-islam-permit-bidding-in-auctions -> Halal
https://islamqa.org/hanafi/daruliftaa/8511 -> Halal
https://konsultasisyariah.com/22125-hukum- jual-beli-lelang.html -> Halal
https://www.rumahfiqih.com/x.php?id=1369833509 -> Halal

information that justifies ...
1) It was from Anas bin Malik that there was an Ansar man who came to meet the Holy Prophet and he asked for something from the Holy Prophet. The Holy Prophet asked him, "Is there nothing in your house?" The man replied, "There is. Two pieces of cloth, one worn and the other for a mat, and a cup to drink water. "The Holy Prophet said," Then, bring the two items to me. "The man came with him. The Holy Prophet asked, "Who wants to buy this item?" One of his companions replied, "I want to buy it for one dirham." The Holy Prophet asked again, "Anybody want to buy it at a higher price?" The Holy Prophet offered him up to two or three times. Suddenly one of his friends said, "I want to buy it for two dirhams." So the Prophet gave him two items and he took the two dirhams and gave it to the Ansar man ... (Narrated by Ahmad, Abu Dawud, an- Nasa`i, and at-Tirmidhi)

2) It's allowed to make "muzayadah" transaction for loot/ghanimah and inheritance. Jami’ Turmudzi, 3/514

3) I see people (friends) who they buy and sell ghanimah to 'man yazid' people who add price. (Narrated by Bukhari in Muallaq 3/69, and mentioned in Syarh Ma'ani al-Atsar, no. 3935).

Does anyone forbid or condone it? There are also! Basically:
1) I heard the Messenger of Allah (PBUH) banned the sale and purchase of auctions. (HR Al-Bazzar).
2) It was from Ibn Umar that the Messenger of Allah forbade one of you from buying something that was bought by his brother until he left it, except for booty and inheritance.

The problem is, the two hadiths that forbid earlier less strong (https://www.rumahfiqih.com/x.php?id=1369833509)

Are we allowed to overtake then? Yes. The SH is not anybody's yet. However if you are overtaken, don't cry too much. This advice is only for those who'd like to use the legal formal definition though; for those who restrain due to ethical reasons it's okay. With one condition: don't claim something halal as haram


ALLAHu a'lam bisshawaab ...

[IMG][/img]Alih Bahasa

UdinLegug

Orginal Posting

Disini