Minority report on the issue of Chile.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs RU
Good evening, ladies and gentlemen.
An important event happened in Terra’s life today - Chile was expelled from the alliance. Russia happened to be the only participating member to vote against this decision and we find it necessary to elaborate our position on this matter.
Our “pole” on the geopolitical map has never been a monolith. While we’ve all been united by the necessity to repel attacks from ONE, our camp always had some sleeping controversies between particular countries. During the months of global ONE domination these controversies didn’t have much chance to reveal, as we were all struggling for a more important goal most of the time - to survive. However, as soon as TEDEN got the upper-hand in the global war, it certainly gave breathing space for some old and new conflicts of interest.
Since the creation of Terra in its current state, there was no strict rulebook on behaviour for the alliance members towards non-Terra countries. You were supposed to support your co-members in any encounters but apart of that your foreign policy was entirely members own business. For Russia it took months to start cooperating with Romania, for example, even under a threat of annihilation and we’ve never been pushed by the alliance on that matter. At the early days of the alliance that was necessary just to keep a bunch of different countries with various heritage together, but we never heard it has been changed. That’s what makes our alliance not a smaller copy of EDEN, but a sovereign entity.
That being said, we do not find the very fact of Chilean aggressiveness towards Argentina a valid reason to consider having them kicked out from the Alliance. Among the listed charges only the fact of concealing the intention to block Argentina’s advance from the HQ is a real misconduct since manipulating the Alliance is definitely not the way to go. However it should be taken into account that the “malicious” logs are a result of misbehaviour of an individual or few and the results of today's vote have an impact on the whole community. Definitely, that might deserved a warning and probably a sort of punishment, but having a country immediately kicked out is an overreaction to say at least. We also believe that the statement that the only reason of invasion to NZ for Chile was to screw Argentina is an exaggeration anyway. It more reminds of a foolish proverb: “Happiness is not when you feel good, it is when you feel good while the neighbour feels bad”. The attitude of Chile to Argentina hasn’t been a secret for anybody, but then again, while Chile is Terra member and Argentina is not, it is their call and we are supposed to deal with it and live with it, trying to soothe the situation diplomatically rather than applying capital punishment.
We’d be happy to be mistaken, but honestly the whole situation leaves an impression that Terra decided to pick the most simple solution to a complicated problem. However this solution contradicts almost everything in the Manifesto stated in the Terra newspaper recently. The main objectives for the months were supposed to be improving communication and solving diplomatic issues. And the way Chilean issue is resolved isn’t helping those goals at all.
We respect the decision of the voters, but are greatly disappointed with it. We are not only clearly pushing an ally towards the enemies’ camp, we are doing that while compromising our identity. Because we are not just a bunch of randomly picked countries sharing MPPs and few irc-chats as long as it stays comfortable, are we?
Sincerely,
nimnul, CP of eRussia
mogaba, MoFA of eRussia
Русская версия.:
Добрый вечер, дамы и господа.
Сегодня в жизни Терры произошло важное событие - из альянса была исключена Республика Чили. Россия оказалась единственной страной, проголосовавшей против такого решения и мы считаем необходимым прояснить свою позицию по данному вопросу.
Наш “полюс” на геополитической карты никогда не был монолитом. Хотя мы все были объединены необходимостью отражать атаки ОНЕ, наш лагерь никогда не был лишен некоторых “спящих” противоречий между отдельными странами. На протяжении месяцев глобального доминирования ОНЕ эти противоречия имели немного шансов проявить себя, так как у всех нас постоянно была гораздо более важная цель - выжить. Однако с тех пор как ТЕДЕН перехватил лидерство в глобальной войне, появилось свободное время для старых и новых конфликтов интересов.
С момента создания Терры в ее текущем виде не существовало никаких сводов правил по поводу поведения членов альянса в отношении нечленов Терры. Предполагалось, что вы должны оказывать полную поддержку другим членам альянса в любых затруднениях, но помимо этого внешняя политика являлась вашим личным делом. Например, для России заняло несколько месяцев, прежде, чем она начала сотрудничать с Румынией, даже перед угрозой уничтожения. И альянс никогда на нас в этом вопросе не давил. На заре альянса это было необходимо хотя бы для того, чтобы удержать вместе горстку разных стран с различным “багажом”, однако нам не известно, чтобы с тех пор что-либо менялось. Это то, что делает наш альянс не просто уменьшенным клоном ЭДЕН, а самостоятельной сущностью.
Исходя из сказанного, мы не считаем, что сам факт агрессивного отношения Чили по отношению к Аргентине является достаточной причиной для того чтобы ставить вопрос об их исключении из Альянса. Из всего списка обвинений только факт сокрытия намерения заблокировать вторжение Аргентины в Новую Зеландию действительно является проступком, так как манипулирование альянсом недопустимо. Тем не менее, следует учесть, что эти “зловредные” логи - плод действий одного или нескольких человек, а сегодняшнее голосование окажет воздействие на целое коммьюнити. Безусловно, возможно такие действия заслуживали предупреждения или даже наказания, но немедленное исключение из альянса явно неадекватная реакция. Кроме того, мы полагаем, что утверждение о том, что единственной причиной вторжения в Новую Зеландию для Чили является насолить Аргентине - это преувеличение. Скорее это напоминает шутливую поговорку: “Счастье это не когда тебе хорошо, но когда тебе хорошо, а соседу - плохо.” Отношение Чили к Аргентине не являлось секретом ни для кого, но опять же, пока Чили - член Терры, а Аргентина - нет, это их выбор и мы должны его принять и жить с ним, пытаясь смягчить ситуацию дипломатически, а не рубить голову.
Мы были бы рады ошибиться, но честно говоря, общая ситуация оставляет впечатление, что Терра решила применить самое простое решение к сложной проблеме. Тем не менее, это решение противоречит почти всему высказанному недавно в Манифесте в газете альянса. Главными задачами на этот месяц должны были быть улучшение взаимопонимания и разрешение дипломатических проблем. И способ которым был решен Чилийский вопрос никак этим задачам не соответствует.
Мы уважаем решение проголосовавших, но сильно им разочарованы. Мы не только открыто подталкиваем союзника в сторону вражеского лагеря, мы делаем это компрометируя собственное “я”. Ведь мы не просто горстка случайно выбранных стран у которых общие МПП и пара ИРЦ-чатиков, пока это просто и комфортно, не так ли?
Президент nimnul
МИД mogaba.
Comments
voted
ВОТЕ НИМНУЛ!!!
ВОТЕ МОГАБА!!!
ВОТЕ МОГАБА!
o7
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
the fact is that the actual SG of TERRA is an argentinian lover, the fight against the argentinians RW never was a government orders, anyway this was gonna happen with the fall of ONE, so actually i don't care, this is time of the true friends an allies
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Respect!
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
voted from Ireland
Hail Russia
Hail Bulgaria
Hail Chile
"We respect the decision of the voters, but are greatly disappointed with it. We are not only clearly pushing an ally towards the enemies’ camp, we are doing that while compromising our identity. Because we are not just a bunch of randomly picked countries sharing MPPs and few irc-chats as long as it stays comfortable, are we?"
Thanks
POlitics: FUUUUU!!!
Hail Friends! \o/
A почему не написал это по-русски? Мы хотим русский перевод.... спасибо!
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
como diria la pela tomate
CONCHATUMADRE ME SUPERAI
HAIL RUSSIA
HAIL CHILE
GO GO GO
MAS TEMPRANO QUE TARDE ♪♪CAERA EL COBARDE♪♪
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
HAIL RUSSIA
HAIL CHILE
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Hail Ireland!
Hail India!
Hail China!
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
ВОТЕ НИМНУЛ!!!
ВОТЕ МОГАБА!!!
Not to mention that Argentina fought against Russia while it was part of TERRA and against Bulgaria again while part of TERRA for months and did not get "punished" for it. This is double standards but we have to give it to ONE they did win a great diplomatic win buy recognizing the biggest weakness of our alliances, greed for power of a small elite, same as the one that brought down their alliance before.
HAIL RUSSIA...
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
voted
o7
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
terra should kick russia's ass too
Great article, congrats and respect! ...
Terra HQ should definitively learn something from you guys
Hail Russia!
Hail Russia! o7
Hail Chile! o7
Hail Bulgaria! o7
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Siempre con honor, no nos bajamos los pantalones ante nadie.
ВОТЕ МОГАБА !!!
Hail Russia! Hail Chile! Hail Bulgaria!
You can see this problem the way you want.. But understand that Argentina is a country that ALWAYS help our allies, and we have a lot of damage to do.. But instead of giving the best to our allies, we have to be fighting chile in our own rws, because they dont care about anyone but themselves.. Why you dont ask chilenian guys to fight for you instead of hitting against argentina? That would be excelent for the alliance.
Think it that way, and you will see why they are out of terra.
TEDEN is dead. They just don't know it yet.
Lies, Chile has always fought for their allies, they helped us in numerous battles. It was Argentina who fought against it's supposed allies, they fought vs Bulgaria many times while being part of Terra. Heck, they even left Terra lol why is Chile kicked out because of a non-terra country? ah yes, because they do less dmg.
Screw you Damagehood! You are going down!
спасибо
HAIL RUSSIA !!
Respect!
HAIL RUSIA
HAIL CHILE
HAIL BULGARIA
HAIL COLOMBIA
o7
Hail vodka
Hail beer
Hail red hot chilly peppers!
this decition is the first step to revival ONE alliance, but TEDEN is broken...
TERRA HQ AND EDEN HQ Prefer two contry out of alliance..
HAIL BULGARIA
HAIL CHILE
HAIL TEDEN PEOPLE
FAIL TEDEN HQ.
eDarkAngel + Wildrunner: Our situation with eIndonesia and eTurkey was official, we fought for them and we said that. When we saw that being part of an alliance could cause us troubles with them, we left.
What about eChile, asking for TERRA cooperation in their "invasion" of eNZ, while it actually was a "protection" war? Does not matter that eArg wanted that region. The problem was that eChile wanted to protect an enemy of TEDEN and lied about it.
In Russia we trust! o7
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Ireland!
Hail Bulgaria!
It's time for a change!
Great article, congrats and respect! ...
Terra HQ should definitively learn something from you guys
Hail Russia!
x2
Hail Russia!
Hail Chile!
Hail Bulgaria!
Hail Ireland!
Hail India!
Hail China!
v
V
it is sad to see all TEDEn countries fighting each other and not against ONE.
And worst of all is that this looks like the Star Wars .. ONE achievement infiltrate two of their pets in the ranks of TERRA and EDEN.
TURKEY ARGENTINA FAIL FAIL.
Vote from Ireland
Vote from Ireland
o/