Nebula - a Retrospective on a Month as MoFA
James Rellori
Ineffective
adjective - in·ef·fec·tive
“not capable of performing efficiently or as expected”
- Merriam-Webster definition
Over the last month, I have had the honour of serving as Minister of Foreign Affairs to Henry the 8th. However, I had the displeasure of having to deal with Nebula, the most internally ineffective alliance with no clear chain of command.
The first point I started to realise that Nebula was faulty was two days into the job, seeing that there was a vote done without eAustralia present. (Due to IRC meetings being between 2am-5am). I then started to loathe it about halfway through the term with Infowars, Brigidd and others trying to get eAustralia to airstrike Mexico, despite the constant cries of “Nebula is a defensive alliance!”
Nebula is eRepublik’s FIFA at the moment. Let's get rid of the old guys and their corrupt ways!
Here’s some of my problems and solutions to fixing Nebula:
1. MU commanders have too much power
MU commanders should be there to follow orders and set orders according to what Nebula wishes, not the other way around. Over the last month I have seen the chaos in Nebula first hand with battles chosen on a whim. (For example: The AS on Denmark. I’ve searched through the command thread constantly and found nothing about any vote on the issue along with any real opposition to the proposal bombarded with insults from the Infowars/Brigidd wing of the alliance.)
This issue can be fixed by ensuring that people who shouldn’t be in the command thread, shouldn’t be there. The main council thread should be exclusive for Nebula Command and key government representatives. Keep any MU’s out of the thread and put them into their own thread.
Some evidence for your perusal (And this is just mostly evidence of Infowars abusing Nebula!): Picture 1 Picture 2 Picture 3
2. There's no real democracy.
I have spent a large portion of the month just trying to figure out where these Nebula captain calls are coming from. Its clear that quite a bit of the voting happens within IRC meetings (Which are at inconvenient times for eAustralia, as usual) if voting is happening at all.
Easy fix, democratise Nebula, give at least a 12 hour window for countries to formulate their decision and vote.
Evidence (With a little more added humour when thinking about Denmark/Germany) : Picture 4
3. Nebula doesn’t have enough damage to protect its own members.
This lack of damage on Nebula’s part results in the requirement for deals with other alliances. This results in quite a large part of Nebula’s time to be spent dealing with business rather than war.
This is not an easily fixable problem and I do not expect it to go away anytime soon but nonetheless is still a problem. One possible fix may be to remember that they are a defensive alliance, not offensive.
Conclusion: How would I fix all of these problems?
I believe that Nebula needs a total reform which keeps MU’s secondary to government. Which makes sure that the MU’s main role is to follow orders at the discretion of the governments of the day, not give the orders for government to follow.
A perfect Nebula would involve a new charter, a democratised system of decisions, more powerful countries, a HQ which is willing to punish MU’s which step out of line and try to start calling the shots.
Finally, the main influence we need to eradicate from Nebula is those there to simply influence Nebula into serving as their own personal army to enforce their opinions. Nebula is not a playtoy of powerful MU’s, it's an alliance which works towards common goals.
Nebula, an alliance which takes it name from a cloud of dust, impenetrable to external view, certainly lives up to this name.
James Rellori
Australian Minister of Foreign Affairs
Oh… and here's Infowars being rude towards people with differing opinions, I imagine he'll continue this long tradition of his in the comments below!
Comments
"Ineffective"
Are you talking about yourself, right? xD
More effective than Varnish is at actually getting off their asses and doing something. Seriously XenthuS, your varnish guys in congress are terrible.
Indeed, you're the most effective guy doing nothing and not getting MPPs, i give you that.
So terrible that the masspm haven't been created by the Goverment and noone talks in the forum, shame on Varnish guys!
Give it a rest Xenthus, have you made the effort to start the senate thread?
No? Well STFU
XenthuS, I didn't seek out new MPP's because we didn't need to. Sadly Infowars decided to take it upon himself and pretend to be MoFA to seek them for us. Shame Infowars Shame!
You kidding? We were being wiped by Turkey and we didn't need them :?
Are you serious? Or it's just that you didn't see the turkish AS?
I like how you work: Varnish guys's faults, NEBULA's faults, Infowar's faults... Could you start to think that you are the problem here?
I did see the Turkish AS. I didn't see it as a big problem and I knew that Nebula could help fight it off. (Serving its purpose as a defensive alliance)
It was agreed on by someone that there would be no mass PM, because forum is soooo much better...
Still you didn't inform senate in the forum about the AS, why you didn't? Doesn't matter if it has to be in a massmp or in a forum, you didn't inform or discuss nothing with the senate members or the rest of the population... xD
You're a useless figurehead JR, you can complain all that you want but it's the only truth here... Infowar and NEBULA can say whatever they want but YOU were the ones who launch the AS and signed the MPP, it was YOU not them, YOU (Henry)
XenthuS, the whole thing was planned by Infowar and brigidd in the NEBULA thread in about 2 days, HT8 was pressured into passing the AS.
I funded it so that eAustralia wouldn't look like as much of a douche if it failed.
You're wrong, that's exactly how Australia looks right now or even worse with the goverment crying that all this evil NEBULA's fault... xD
''More effective than Varnish is at actually getting off their asses and doing something.'' And WTF did you do yourself the entire term???
''Sadly Infowars decided to take it upon himself and pretend to be MoFA to seek them for us. Shame Infowars Shame!''
It's called preparing for an Airstrike.. You know how hard it is to get some of those MPPs which I got? Also Pr3zzy and I paid for most of them, so what do you care?
[removed]
Strange how everyone is blaming people outside the government for things which the government are responsible for. e.g: Isn't it the CP's job to create senate threads? Or make someone else create it?
Isn't it the MoFA team's job to publish articles informing the public about Airstrikes and so forth?
Except the government had literally nothing to do with it except pressing the buttons...
I guess all of this could have been avoided if we (the government) did something fun during the term... Between being stonewalled by USA, and having support for any battles except on Indo regions removed by BS there really wasn't any options..
Also it was agreed we wouldn't have a senate thread this month... That worked well...
I want to go on record as being against being self-dicked until we work that shit out... We are not much better of now than we were under BS dictatorship...
I agree that NEBULA has been misused and lead astray by a shadow government. From the stuff I have seen, for an MU leader to dictate what should be done to an alliance is completely wrong. Then to read the insults being thrown after the MU bad ideas have been squashed is even worse.
The problem is there is an old guard. That one needs to change. People in NEBULA need leadership that can actually think and analyse what needs to be done. Also as you pointed out strength is an issue.
Due to the current strength of NEBULA , defence is the only real option .Later as the alliance grows (strength wise), then it can look at co-ordinated attacks. Plus why do an AS when half the countries are battling elsewhere ??
If it wants to be co-ordinated , pick a week, clear every countries schedule and then smack the crap out of the target together
why not me 😛
I'm old enough to know people, and I've not truley lead anything be4 unless its a small minister role or senator 😛
I agree with what you are saying there.. But we wanted it for the tournament and there was an opportunity to coordinate attacks with other allies, but Henry didn't press the button soon enough, it put everything out..
The other reason was we wanted another fight so everyone could get more TP damage and gold from the tournament.
so you screw up relations with other countries for a pitiful amount of gold in a tournament? ever heard of a training war for tournament sakes?
And now your saying it wasnt to help a country to get into NEBULA?? please stick to one reason and stand by it.
''And now your saying it wasnt to help a country to get into NEBULA?? please stick to one reason and stand by it.''
No I am saying that there were a few reasons. One was to help out the Netherlands, second was the tournament, that is part of the reason it was rushed. And there are other reasons.
There is more to it than what I can say here. We may screw relations up with one country, but we will strengthened relations with others as we help them against a common enemy..
Infowar, I have the transcripts, I know what your reasons are. But people will always question you if you go from one story to another.
Saying the tournament made it rushed, is a bit far fetched since the tournament was not over night.
In regards to screwing up relations... I personally think you have done more damage then good, but hey, every month there is a new CP... just hope 8 months later Germany dont say 'Oh 8 months ago Australia tried to AS us, even though it was ages ago, lets get revenge'.
Also the funny thing is JR, even after being called everything from f...tard to traitor, someone still was asking me to put money towards their stupid failed AS.
I also love how the original conversation was not fully presented, just the bits that suited the Infowar/Brigidd factor
Please post the original conversation.
I will be... Just been slack in my article writing
That wasn't deliberate. That information was given to me before the rest of it had been communicated. Also I think you made those comments before you knew what was really going on at that moment. So I believed that you were supporting Germany at the time, then I found out later the rest of the information
I knew what was going on from the start, Brigidd told me it was to hit Germany. And as I said to her, it was a stupid idea. The part about me saying I would put CO's against the AS was later in the convo, so it should of been all brought to you. The reason I didn't was because, as I stated, Germany wasn't going to let their colony fall.
Plus if I was supporting Germany at the time, I would of waited until you struck Germany and not suggest if the final target was Germany, hit that rather then Denmark.
Like I said to you already there is more to it than I can say publicly. But I could tell you in private sometime.
"The part about me saying I would put CO's against the AS was later in the convo, so it should of been all brought to you. The reason I didn't was because, as I stated, Germany wasn't going to let their colony fall."
To be honest, I didn't read the whole convo. Brigidd just told me that you were threatening to put COs on for the Germans. Then she showed me that shapshot.
So the reason why you didn't is because Germany had enough COs to get through it? But if they ran out or lost support you would have? Is that what you meant to say?
Doubt you will get the rise out of him James, while the election approaches he needs his farts smelling like roses, hence the Germark Assault article.
Agree with Rusty's Old guard strangle on Nebula, needs to be stomped on.
By the looks of things the old guard will remain. So I guess we have to prepare for another wasted AS, we have had Swiss, almost had Mexico, the Denmark... Who's next in this hair brained ideas, maybe USA or UK or even Brazil (because once upon a time a Brazilian girl told Infowar to get lost)
good article
good pics
good content
by a great guy 🙂
nice to see you writing again james, need more shit from you, you've always got the smarts, and I look forward to what else you have to put forward
Thanks SirJames244, just don't inflate my ego too much! 😉
The conversation ss between Info and Mac was very disturbing-- Most of the countries Info listed are friends of ours that at one time would not have hesitated to have an MPP with eAus.
The lack of information coming out of the alliance is also disturbing. We should not have to wait until after the fact to know the justification for why our country AS'd someone. No, there is no congress thread-- but there is a cabinet thread, and presumably most of the Australian gov have friended each other-- and anyone can publish an article-- so there is really no excuse.
And +1 for bravery, James.
Infowar is not in the Cabinet thread. 2 Points on that,
1. Why did he plan an AS, his only contact with ,most people about it was spamming the NEBULA thread (which it is debatable if he should've been in)
2. MPP's he setup most likely didn't happen because he (for lack of a better phrase) isn't important in this government setup, countries like Serbia would be like... wtf why is he asking us?
Brigidd said like 3 times in the NEBULA thread (to get HT8 to start the AS) that she would put out an article about it as soon as he voted yes on the AS.
I like how infowar tried to deflect all this shit evenly onto me and him by saying 'me and pr3zzyy decided this' etc, all I did was offer to pay for it so that government wouldn't waste 200k CC + CO's... and stop him from talking Norway into NE'ing Germany and ultimately ending up wiped..
Seriously though we had been talking about it for about 2 days before it happened, and just before the campaign started (I think within 24 hours before it started) 4 TRAINING WARS STARTED WITH OTHER NEBULA COUNTRIES !?!
I know... its complete madness how Nebula is acting at the moment.
Then again Germany was pissing up CO's like there was no tomorrow...
Prez, are you saying that Nebula voted to support the AS, when 4 of the countries already knew they had TW planned?
Yes
Pretty much no-one but me and HT8 even tried to find any problems with the AS plan, but don't quote me on that because I haven't looked back to check.
I have always had the greatest respect for the intellect of most of Nebula's HQ. Now I am starting to wonder what is going on in there. They should maybe stop drinking Info's koolaid. 😉
Prez, I tried to contact people, but instead I was called a traitor by others. At least Henry hesitated because he saw the light and the fact Infowar could organise a root in a brothel
HT8 was actually extremely hesitant about doing it, what I can't believe is that NEBULA was holding Infowar's opinion higher than that of the CP of eAus.
''I like how infowar tried to deflect all this shit evenly onto me and him by saying 'me and pr3zzyy decided this' etc,''
The only reason why I said that was because last time I made a comment like that in which I didn't mention your name I think you got a little upset that you didn't get the credit. Otherwise I wouldn't care less to just say "I" If that's what you want then next time I won't mention your name.. But if a campaign succeeds, you would want me to mention your name right 😃
Not really... i don't like limelight @_@
Good or bad... Although I am unsure which of those categories this would fit into...
I wouldn't mind in either case you saying it was 'privately funded' by me or something...
JR, I'm going to try and be objective here...
Your SS of private messages are not particularly damning. With the parts you can see (please, excuse my crappy PC running IE11) it looks like part of a robust conversation/debate rather that anything else. You should know Aussies like to invoke profanities when they get excited (f... knows I do!).
Your point about coordination is well made. We can always do better. 🙂 Have you referred any of these points onto the alliance command? Should we expect them to comment overnight??
What's the process for people being appointed to the command thread? I don't think I've seen any advertisements for any position...
What would any sort of punishment for MUs look like? How do you compel anyone to do anything in this game...