The beginning of the end of eRep?
ligtreb
Yes, a lot of the events of Day 953 were entertaining. In case you missed it:
admin was banned.
As were many other prominent citizens.
Multiple prominent newspapers were hacked as well, check the eUS forums for more info.
While I laughed at first, I was disturbed later on. This should never happen.
This all started when one community moderator leaked his password in a fit of rage. People then used it to to ban citizens and hack newspapers. While the bans have been rolled back, friend lists have been lost, as have congressional seats, party president spots and presidential endorsements.
One moderator giving up his password should not be able to lead to the banning of dozens of prominent citizens, the takeover of prominent newspapers and the loss of elected positions. No citizen should have that much unchecked power.
That's not even the worst part.
The password was leaked around 17:15 game time. The admins did not put the servers under maintenance until 23:30, and no visible action was taken to stop the chaos before then.
There is no excuse for letting the chaos continue for over six hours. I understand that this was nighttime in Europe, where the admins are located. Is there not one night owl on the eRepublik staff? Not one person up early in the morning? (23:30 is 9:30 a.m. in Romania).
A lot of people pay real money for this game. This game has real investors. And there are several country populations in this game who are active during nighttime in Europe: USA, Brazil, Indonesia, China, Canada, Japan to name a few.
I lost a lot of trust in this game, and I'm sure many eRepublik players did as well. I'm not quitting this game, I have made tons of friends here. I may be the exception. Without swift action to make sure this never happens again, many people may quit.
I've defended this game and the admins in the past. This is a great game, it really is. But they need to make sure this game is safe from something like this happening again -- no player should have this much unchecked power. I wrote this article in hopes that the incident of Day 953 will inspire the admins to reform their moderator system. I'm hoping they succeed.
Comments
sofa
it was the v2 bugs that did it. v2 sux
Agreed with everything you said, ligtreb
I agree with this article. Last night was unacceptable.
Vote!
Agree 🙂
vote
😛
A lot of people do pay to play this game. I like lulz as much as anyone...
but...
WTF
really lol!
one should never pay real money for this game , that has been proved
"one should never pay real money for this game , that has been proved "
QFT
It's great how one lowly mod can cause 6 hours of chaos.
Voted.
So first you lol'd but then you serious'd.
reform their moderator-system - like disband the game mods.
Good grief
Agree, that's awesome ....
They should have rolled back the whole game. Reversing the bans doesn't repair any of the damage.
The one time that stupid chicken would be useful...
... and it was nowhere to be found :/
whoever doesnt vote this after reading it should quit playing this game
just shows how easy it is to ban people...
You are mostly right however
" no player should have this much unchecked power. "
well lets think about it.
There is lots of multi users. So for stop them, overpowered admins needed.
And that power will given more players for v2. Because there will be more and more multies. So how could they stop them 😒
The problem is:
GOLD!
You're fukin' brilliant. Thank you for all the laughs and for, once again, proving that admins are just NOT READY FOR EVEN MORE COMPLEX VERSION when they have trouble keeping this one 'normal' as it is.
Six hours of NO ACTIONS? For Google's sake.
Once again, thank you! 'Twas the funniest day for me since the beginning of eRep.
"Six hours of NO ACTIONS? For Google's sake."
hell right 🙂
Their comment: http://forum.erepublik.com/showthread.php/99028-Official-Statement-about-the-issue-that-encountered-in-the-Day-953">http://forum.erepublik.com/showthread.ph[..]y-953
i agree wholeheartedly voted! 😮
Voted hard.
voted.
ligtreb, blame on admins for stupid enough to give password to a citizen.
Voted.
voted
Ligtreb FTW!
What we also have to look at is how many active, invested players took advantage of using the mod tools yesterday. This is a sign that the game is driving off its core players. Players are willing to lose everything they worked at for one night of anarchistic protest. That says a lot. This truly is the beginning of an end. More than just a canary in a coalmine, but a couple of miners croaking before your eyes.
Great article Ligtreb.
I don't know what is more disturbing - the fact that a _player_ who does not face any legal responsibility for his actions is able to do this much harm or the supposed reasons why he did it.
I haven't heard the real reasons, but there are rumors that what GF did was basically an act of protest against egregious acts of abuse done by other community moderators. Recently, during the UK landbridge operations, some members of EDEN were DDoSed at a precise strategically important moment. Their IPs had to be leaked out from somewhere...
truer words have never been written Lig... unfortunately it does show a major security leak and obviously community mods have far too much power without major checks/balances. Having one mod account being able to ban more than 2 or 3 people in a period of time without having Admin approval or checks is ridiculous and borderline stupid.
Voted.
Ligtreb is right.
While I believe that one person having this kind of power is in fact neccessary to maintaining a game, the people given this kind of power should be people that can be trusted. Keep in mind that to get rid of cheaters, banning is probably the best way, but I think that one of two things should be done:
1. The amount of people given this kind of power should be smaller and these people should only be people who can truly be trusted.
2. Like Speedcat said, one mod should only be able to ban "2 or 3 people in a period of time without having Admin approval"
Just my 2 cents
signed and voted
Just putting it out there, after the servers went down, I could still ban people
<3
Wpack
They did it for the lulz
I dont agree with the title, but I agree whole heartedly with this article. Voted.
gotta' throw this out there. GF didn't quit due to V2. He didn't quit because of the Admins.
He quit because he was burnt out and the game had become a second life to him. He quit because the players were assholes.
So he ragequitted because of YOU, the PLAYERS, not the admins.
I would like to see every people involved in this chaos banned.
Even the 2 ex presidents of the USA. Same on them. They acted like 10 year old childrens and all the others to.
lol I was banned too
I completely agree,
the bugs of this game are annoying.
Ligtreb for POTUS.
Ligtreb is the smartest player I know.
I agree. But I also want to say thaks admins for a great game.