On Communes. On the Irish Army.
Death and Taxes
There are two good articles in the press that are not getting the attention they deserve. Partly this is down to the authors not wishing to promote their articles, and partly down to the subjects not being of great interest to your average citizen.
This is a great shame, because you all should take an interest in these seemingly tedious issues of taxes, communes and the economy. You can catch these articles here:
Kaptain Kidd writes about treasury and taxes: http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/taxes-responsibility-and-common-sense-2300733/1/20
Mary Robinson asks a pertinent question about communes here: http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/prevailing-wage-vs-commune--2300800/1/20
I'm going to combine these issues in the light of recent changes to the military module. You should all be aware of what these changes are. But before we go there we need to deal with some very simple basic facts.
First. No matter what the admins do, with the exception of finite energy bars, all of us are restricted in that we can only recoup 2400 energy per day. Well duh. Furthermore, because few of us take this game seriously enough to put matchsticks in our eyes, the maximum realistic energy you can recover is 2200.
Second. If we use Q7 weapons for damage purposes, then we'll need 22 Q7 weapons to get us through the day successfully or approximately 220IEP. We'll conveniently ignore the food required and the variable requirements we all have with our training regimes.
Third. That in order to fund this deficit we need gainful employment.
This can take three forms. The first is where you work for somebody and receive a cash benefit. Typically this is about 10 IEP per day. I don't recommend this. Second option is to work in your MU commune. Unfortunately, many communes utilise outside merchants, typically this will mean you get paid up to 4Q7 to 7Q7 weapons per day.
In Ireland we have one hell of a commune in the Irish Army. Because James Keiller runs our commune in Serbia (of all places - but we need the 10/10 bonuses) and operates a not-for-profit business, we all get 10Q7 shiny weapons every day. Trust me on this, we are very much the exception to the rule.
OK - so here's the moderately interesting bit. The changes to the military module with MU combat orders now allows us to earn enough money to cover our day-to-day costs depending on your damage output. For myself, if I got a full run of combat orders I'll generate something like 320IEP.
So I have a set of proposals.
Firstly, where possible, we should prioritise the DO's that include combat orders. Obviously, this should have MPP priorities or at worst, countries we feel we have something in common with. For example, I am currently stationed in Russia and can avail of either a 40 or 30IEP offer from Chile to fight against Argentina, with no travel costs, something I am only too happy to oblige.
Secondly, that the present commune system is now broken and needs to be modified to take into account combat orders. Therefore I recommend that certain IA members who are exceedingly active in D3 and D4 have their daily Q7 reward changed. It is my belief that while the 10Q7 rebate should still be given, that these players should donate a percentage of their IEP earnings to the MU via the donation button.
Thirdly, that this money should be used for vital campaigns defined by the MoD where the IA will use these proceeds to fund damage to influence the war. Typically this would be RW's for Ireland, or vital campaigns for our MPP's. This very visible assistance to our allies would bring more kudos to the IA and our country that a month's worth of words and diplomacy.
To give an example, if I was to give 100IEP per day to the MU org it will work out at 3000IEP at the end of this month. If we can get 10 members - asking a lot I know - to contribute in a similar fashion, then we'd have 30,000IEP sitting in our org account at the end of a month. At 40IEP per million in D4, this would buy us 750m damage in a campaign of our choice.
The neat bit, is that quite a lot of this money will be repatriated to Irish citizens fighting in this same campaign. It really would be a win/win situation.
So what say you?
Comments
Very interesting. I like the analysis. That could be a plus for Ireland. And everyone else of course.
I wonder what it will do to strategy.
I like the article, but did you just put random pictures (with the exception of young Tiberius) into it?
Mostly the pictures are irrelevant and are there just to break up wall of text. However, I think it's important to trump the various Star War threads by highlighting how you reboot a franchise. Are you listening George Lucas, oh wait, you don't have a say anymore...
3,000 * 30 = 30,000 ???
Nah, I meant 10. 30 contributors would be crazily optimistic. *fixed*
Lots of possibilities thrown up by the new combat orders. Thought provoking article. v
So Malbekh want members IA to became a whores and fight only for those who pays?
And then Malbekh whine about merc medal..
Malbekh you might be suitable for that life style but i am sure members of IA still have some proud left.
Lets not forget members of irish army are already insulted on daily basis by having open traitor conway in their ranks....
Why would members of irish army give anything of what they earn?
Its their money and they can use it to strenghten themselfs and that will strenghten Ireland.
Like true member of kunts Malbekh only seek a new way to use other people's money.
And lets not forget a crusial fact that funds are not only limited but also depends on rewquirements.
What if requirement is it must be below 52% but it gets higher for most of the time of battle?
IA members will get shit of that money.
Often offered money expire after 10-20 minutes from beginning of the battle.
Basically the stronger players will take the cream of that funds while weaker will get shit.
What then?
Will every member of irish army have to justify themself? To explain why they did not donate a certain amount of money?
Leave irish army alone with your retarded ideas Malbekh and go back to defending thiefs and traitors.....not that you are good at that as well...
Oh, this is such an easy one.
This is none of your business as you're not in the IA.
You have never run a commune or supply chain in your life so, as usual, you don't know what you're talking about
If you knew how the IA was funded you wouldn't write the BS you do, the fact of the matter is that the IA is over-generous on supplies
Should you not be off in Wales(Poland) or NW England (UK) or NFL (Spain) working on your 18th traitor medal, rather than making up garbage with crayons?
nah i am in germany working on 36th country i will save from herezy.
As State Prior everything in Ireland is my business..especially if someone like you who spend days in defending thiefs and traitors.
Basically...everything you write has to be automatically considering malicious and against ireland.
and after close inspection i came to conclusion....it is.
And you said this will be easy...but...you did not respond to any of my claims..
You just started with your usual drama queen crap.
IA is a state army and self sufficant or not it's government's job to make sure supplies are there...
Members already do their party by following orders and actually WORKING for their suplies.
Members of IA do not deserve to be exploited by prasites like you.
Tell you what Kurgan, get the chrome add-on for eGOV4U and we'll track your movements and see where the damage goes. I think you'll find your traitor medals harder to come by. In relation to the IA, seeing as you constantly criticise the government = Sweet + Apple as well as the commander and MoD = Seanan. You really don't have anything to contribute to the argument.
Malbekh you know how stupid you look tryng to demonise merc medals and in the same time lying how conway retuned money he stole from government?
And if you have any brain you would know there are numerous ways to get merc medal without influencing anything.
I already against wich countries a never fight against and for...the rest i don't give a shit....
By the way your friend conway openly stated his treason against ireland and will to fight for britain against ireland...
But you keep defend this sort of filth...
I'm not demonising merc medals, I'm demonising you as you have 17 of them. I'm not defending Conway, I'm just showing you up for the fantasist that you are. You based your claims on a Dan Breen article, who you have said was a scammer and a con artist, whereas we know that 100k was returned just as Conway said he did. Besides we know the real reason why you hate Conway so much...
actually if you fill your bar before you go to sleep you will have 1300 energy(in my case) available at the beginning of the next day. you can therefore use 3700 energy in that day. yes it averages out but still you can have more available in a day.
Yes, you can micro burst and save up your energy but it's not relevant as we are talking about medians.
also correction not everyone is getting 10 Q7 WEPS a day. I would say my average is around 7 or 8. but I sometimes get a small travel allowance as well.
Secondly not certain DO's work as you suggest. Will waste some energy bars to check but think you get for your Daily Do still 5 Bazooka Parts and a energy bar. Only for your second none MU DO do you get the prizes. Not certain will have to check as I said. As to Donations I already give most of my food away I think that is enough for a senior member. Wouldnt like to create a requirement or expectancy as after all you can get in a scenario where your income drop to 100 IEP a day quickly. Also I already promised some gold and food to the IA in my competition which only Kurgan is supporting. I fthere is no interest in our give aways I wont bother anymore because I am anyway not doing it for any reason but perhaps kindness.
If that's the case about younger soldiers getting less weapons then this is wrong. Other countries/communes tend to favour the younger members as the older ones are usually self-sufficient. As for the rest of the stuff, I have no idea what you are talking about. What I'm talking about is doubling up on the DO with combat orders where possible. The reason is that you are wasting 25 kills = 750 energy that could be used for both.
ok checked it out. problems i have atm with the system is you cant see what the command order is(do order is a seperate system) anyway yes make do co's. you cant see from the battle lists perhaps you can enter the battle and see but that is cumbersome. i entered boznia one travel cost was 80 iep i only offered 20 IEP per 1 million damage which is lousy.
Cork! 😉
I fully intend to offer LPA monies on Irish battles, which is basically going to be Cork, unless we can somehow negotiate the return of the other two counties. I've already tried it in the Canadian AS to get a feel for it. Obviously the IA is going to be the bigger contributor for this as they have more members so, potentially, more funds to be able to offer. The other minor point RTK has already mentioned in that you only get 10 Q7s in the IA commune if you use 10 Q7s the day before.
Ah, OK. Why on earth would you not use the 10Q7 weapons? I would have thought that the max weapons should only be given to those that are 7/7. I guess maybe the dedication isn't there any more.
I presume players only doing the DO, who are only going to use 4 or 5 Q7 for their 25 kills.
Nope. Average hits per kill is 3. So you need 3*25 = 750 energy to complete the DO. Besides which, members can see how many kills you did yesterday. So 8Q7 is the minimum to allow for a successful DO
It usually takes me about 600 health to do 25 kills. I'm not sure what that equates to in Q7s but I'd guess maybe 6, possibly 7. Same general point, though. If players just do their DO, they don't use 10 Q7.
As a non-div 4 player - I don't want the experience. Some days I don't fight. Some I fight for DO and others for BH. I can get 25 kills with 5.
For me, I can make more money getting BH in low damage battle than I can make with a good paying CO which has high damage.
It took me 450 health and 4 Q7s to do my DO today, so I'd get that plus a bit of cash if I were in an IA commune and I didn't fight again.
As the original proposer of the Army commune system, I believe these changes would not only compliment the commune system as it stands, but is very much in the spirit of the Revolution that created the Irish Army. Soldiers and the country supporting each other in a cooperative sense is very much the idea I put forth three years ago.
I agree. It provides a source of income for the commune other than taxes, at least that's what the article suggests.
A source of income for military purposes yes, and those costs represent a huge proportion of spending.