Good and Bad Effects of Dirt-Cheap Imported Grain
Swagger McSwag
HACIENDA IN LUZON
Currently, our domestic grain companies are being blown away by foreign competition, particularly from Hungary and, more recently, Spain. Despite our 50% taxes on imported grain, they can still peddle they products here at dirt-cheap prices because of their high grain regions, which allow them to produce twice as much grain as companies in medium grain regions (like our companies).
One Q2 Spanish company is even offering grain at a phenomenally low price of 0.52 PHP per unit.
If this continues, our grain sector might collapse and our farmers and millers will be forced to work as oil drillers and iron miners (which is not so bad as long as we have enough companies to accommodate the spillover, and that demand for oil and iron products remain high enough).
On the upside, though, the dirt-cheap imported grain, aside from the fierce prices wars between companies, have been one of the chief contributing factors in driving our food prices down to record-low levels. If the imported grain goes away, food prices will have nowhere to go but up.
Furthermore, the hefty 50% tariff that we impose on grain imports pose as a lucrative source of income for the government. Although the average unit price of foreign grain is very, very low, it is exactly for this reason our food companies race with each other to take them off the market so that they sell for many hundreds of units per day. Since the government receives HALF of whatever these foreign companies make per unit grain sold, I can only imagine that foreign grain sales make a pretty significant portion of our daily tax revenue.
So, what are we to do?
Shall we protect our local grain companies and the jobs of our farmers by raising import tariffs to force foreign grain companies away from the country?
Or, shall we leave it be, and keep driving the food prices even further down, making them more than accessible to ALL (including minimum wage earners), while accelerating the growth rate of our government revenue?
Your thoughts, comments and opinions are much welcome.
To Congress Members, you may participate in the Congress forum discussion for this topic by following this link: http://ephilippines.forummotion.com/council-of-state-f7/good-and-bad-effects-of-dirt-cheap-foreign-grain-t594.htm
-Ariel, VP of the Philippines
____________________
VOTE AND SUBSCRIBE to The eRepublik Outsider
"Straight News from Inside Sources, Out-of-the-box Commentary"
____________________
The eRepublik Outsider is not to be sold. It is provided as a free public educational service by... me. Some rights reserved. XD
____________________
ADVERTISEMENT: This article is brought to you Bestie101 Realtors. Looking for a Q1, Q2 or Q3 house? Send Bestie101 a message today for free info.
____________________
June 9, 2009
Comments
Voted, people vote this up
voted...
I wish to hear the POC's position here...
hehehe
PGG might be the only shot we got...
In a layman's opinion, I believe that we should take advantage of these cheap grains coming from outside. Because it helps a lot of citizens here gain access to cheap food and the government earns much from it as well.
I think the reason these foreign grain companies decided to export is because the food in their country is secured. I suggest we follow suit and export our products since food here is abundant as well.
we must learn to be flexible.
Well theres a 1% import tax in eAustria for grain and I'm sure there are a couple of other eNations with low import tax on grain, so that option is availible to us.
nice but...
what ABOUT ME?
yes, what about popelus? I miss you dude! pertanax!
@Senor de Minda. Right now, we can't export our food because we don't have a high grain region. Even if we tried to, it would be very hard for our companies because it would be too expensive for them to manufacture food to justify the added costs of import taxes on top of the VAT on top of competition from other companies that source their grain from companies in high grain regions.
To make food exports truly viable for Philippine companies, I think we'd need to lower our grain import taxes to further lower the cost of manufacturing food. We might also want to establish grain companies in high grain regions overseas and import them here to ensure that the supply of cheap grain is constant.
Yeah BOI! Fabian for Congress! hek hek
With the limited knowledge of economics I know, I would tend to agree with Juan de Minda's suggestion. It all boils down to a concept called "comparative advantage". We are a Grain-Medium eNation. We are not the most efficient source of Grain, so we cannot produce all the Grain we need at the lowest and most competitive price. It take us more PHPs for us to produce 1 unit of Grain than it does for other eNations to produce that same 1 unit. Why waste the PHPs?
We should just take advantage of their cheaper prices and allow the Food prices to consequently lower to a more reasonable rate. Then, all the PHPs we saved can be invested in other things that we do have comparative advantage over other counties.
What do you guys think?
i agree that there are benefits and detriments when it comes to imported grains. so the country just needs to take advantage of circumstances that occurs here. 😁
If you push up a tariff wall, the food companies will simply more orgs overseas and buy Grain without paying *any* import taxes.
Grain is a common commodity; most enations have it. oil though has scarcity value: you should be able to make a nice profit trading oil for grain.
As Ariel said, I can't understand why ePhilippines doesn't have a high wood region. Last I checked (looked out the window and felt the heat) the Philippines was mainly tropical rainforest. Used to be, anyway.
This article is the sad truth. I had to close down my company. Taxes need to be raised!!! 99% would be good. Our money is leaving our economy.
@ePCSO
its really true that its hard to compete with foreign companies. i only earn a very small(if not break-even) just to keep up w/ other companies...
what about exporting oil?
That's right!
Let's export Oil.
We'll be like the Arabs.... if we are an Oil-High eNation.
Out of curiosity though, are we?
In palawan, though am I right that oil is only used in producing moving tickets?