On Sovereignty | על הריבונות
•
by I am John Galt
לפני כמה שבועות הצלנו עצמנו (בעזרת הסכם שלום) מידי הכיבוש הקפריסאי וזכינו בריבונות מחודשת.
המצער בדבר שעניין הריבונות לא מובן כהלכה ולא מוצב בראש מענייניו של העם - דבר שיוביל לאיבוד הריבונות שוב.
הרי, מה היא ריבונות? ריבונות היא מאין חרב פיפיות - יש לה חובות וזכויות. ראשית, מזכויותיו של הריבון, שהוא העם, להחזיק בעצמאות, לנהל את ענייניו ולשמור על גבולותיו. שנית, מחובותיו של הריבון לא להסתמך על מדינות זרות ועל תרומות כאלה ואחרות ממדינות ריבוניות אחרות, נוסף על חובתו להימנע מהתעלקות - גם על כוח כובש.
החובה והזכות לא מתקיימות בנפרד ולבד אינן יכולות לקיים ריבונות. אם לא מבצעים את הזכויות הניתנות לריבון - אין ריבונות. אם לא מבצעים את החובות הניתנות לריבון - אין ריבונות.
בשנייה שאין ריבונות אין עצמאות, וכשאין עצמאות אין חירות - לפחות לא בתפישתה הבסיסית והמרכזית, חירות עממית.
על כן, למען לשמור על ריבונותה של ישראל, אל מול איומים עתידיים שיבואו, אין להסתמך על בריתות כאלה ואחרות, ועל הסכמי שלום דומים, אלא רק על הכוח העצמאי של העם. על כל אזרח להיות לוחם וחייל; על כל אזרח להיות שליט בשדה הקרב; על המדינה להיות מעורבת בחיי האזרח בהתייחסות למלחמה; ועל המדינה לעזור לאזרח להפוך להיות לוחם העל הנדרש להגנה עליה.
רק כך אפשר לשמור על ריבונותה של ישראל לאורך זמן, אם לא עד כליון העולם - דבר שהסכמי שלום לא יוכלו להביא. רק כוח.
אם אתם מסכימים עם עמדתי הצטרפו למפלגת החשמונאים - יחד נשנה את ישראל
Several weeks ago we have redeemed ourselves (through a peace agreement) from the hands of the Cypriot occupation and we have regained our sovereignty.
The saddening thing is that sovereignty is misunderstood and is not put at the head of the people's interests - which will lead to the loss of sovereignty once more.
What is sovereignty, in fact? Sovereignty is a kind of a double-edged sword - it has both duties and rights. First, the rights of the sovereign, which is the people, to have independence, are to manage its own affairs and to protect its borders. Second, the duties of the sovereign are not to rely on other nations and on donations from other sovereign states, in addition to its obligation to stay away from leeching - on an occupation force as well.
The duty and the right do not exist separately and alone cannot support sovereignty. If the rights given to the sovereign are not met - there is no sovereignty. If the duties given to the sovereign are not met - there is no sovereignty.
In the second that there is not sovereignty there is no independence, and where there isn't independence there isn't freedom - at least not the central and basic concept, popular freedom.
Thus, in order to preserve the sovereignty of Israel, in front of future threats, there is no relying on different sorts of alliances, nor on peace agreements, but only on the independent force of the people. Every citizen must be a warrior and a soldier; every citizen must be a king in the battlefield; the state must be involved in the affairs of the citizen in regard to war; and the state must help the citizen become the super-soldier needed to protect it.
Only thus the sovereignty of Israel may be preserve in the long run, if not to the end of time - a thing which peace accord cannot preserve. Only force.
If you agree with my position join the Hasmoneans party - Together we will change Israel
Facebook
Twitter
Discord
Comments
As Hasmonean I approve this message! o7
You are playing more then 2 years and still didn't understand the game.
I do, that is why I wrote it. If you have an actual comment about the content, let me know.
You don't understand the game. Because you wrote bullshit "every citizen must be a king in the battlefield". In the game there are only 2 ways to be king.
1. Pay real money and buy a lot of EBs.
2. Fully upgrade TG and visit the game daily for couple years without fighting.
After 2 years your strength is just 606. I get the same strength in 6 days.
I see a proper discussion is impossible without ad hominem here, but nu shoyn.
In any case - that is where governmental intervention is needed - to help citizens excel in the battlefield. I used "a king in the battlefield" as a rhetorical note, sorry if you do not understand that.
Yes, I was not in the game for a long time, and then I returned. Yes, I do not spend my money on gold in the game.
Your only "argument" here is that I'm not good enough to say anything, thus my opinion is null. When you will have something constructive, or actually to the point - please continue your comment. If not, I will kindly request you to cease your commenting.
My only argument is "you wrote bullshit because didn't understand the game". Thus your opinion is null.
And this is constructive - you have to understand why several countries have a lot of regions and others are totally occupied.
Hint - that's not because they think "Every citizen must be a warrior and a soldier; every citizen must be a king in the battlefield; the state must be involved in the affairs of the citizen in regard to war; and the state must help the citizen become the super-soldier needed to protect it."
Of course not, I am not speaking on Imperialism. I'm not calling for the occupation of other regions - I am calling for the preservation of sovereignty. We are not in a place to call for imperialist expansion, we are in a place to construct reforms that could strengthen Israel and preserve its independence.
A good argument doesn't include curses, by the way. Also, my usage of the need for citizen warrior is a rhetoric tool, as I have explained beforem
very funny to read your "the state must be involved in", "the state must help the citizen" and "imperialist expansion". Real John Galt never could write it 🙂
Real John Galt doesn't exist, or the concept of fiction is, to, not understandable to you?
Israel won't be successfull, even succeeding in defending itself, if it won't rely on Alliances.
You have to give up some of your soverignty to keep the rest.
We are too few. When we have a baby boom than we can be more and more independent, but complete soverignty that you are writing about is not possible.
Israel shouldn't cut ties with alliances, of course they're an important assert - but it shouldn't rely on them either. A sovereign Israel needs to be built on military strength. The way to achieve it is, of course, a baby boom - a thing which the education ministry is in charge of.
I understood, but the key to sovereign Israel is to be a reliable ally that our allies can count on. It's not just having good relations with alliances. Israel needs to be part of one. Because an alliance can help defend ourselves.
Of course military strength is important as this is the core element of erep. You can prosper in peace in erep.
Well, yes, again. I am not saying not to be a part of LETO, not at all. You see, the principality that you put on LETO i put on military strength, while the importance of military strength in your eyes is equal to the importance of alliances in my eyes.
Of course we can prosper in peace - that's the whole point of my argument. The question is how to preserve peace, and I believe its throught military force.
i am trying to figure out if this guy is trolling or is actually serious or just saying crazy things hoping someone joins his party
No, I am not trolling, mind you. I would like it if, for once, people would actually dare to comment on my actual ideas and content, and not espouse ratchet ad hominem.
ah in that case your ideas are quite ridiculous and the content would be better suited for a children's fairy tale
Still ad hominem. I see you can't construct an argument, well that's a pitty.
you dont argue with children, you give them instruction and the best instruction i can give you is to take some of the advice that was given to you earlier in the comment section. Until you learn the game you really should not speak so often
I am not a child, but again - you have nothing to say except ad hominem. I do not wish to continue this commenting, mainly because I really don't have the time or the desire to continue speaking to you.
giv d4 active ppl gold and cc for houses and guns - very simple
טוב כמו שהחברים כתבו מעליי אתה כותב שטויות על גבי שטויות על מנת שיצטרפו למפלגתך
"עלייך להיות מלך בשדה הקרב"
עלאק אנחנו צריכים להתייחס פחות לבריתות... בלי בריתות היינו כבושים ולא היה לנו אחוז של סיכוי להשאר על המפה
בקיצור לפני שאתה כותב דברים שמשקפים שאתה לא מבין במשחק לפחות תראה את הכתבה למישהו וותיק וחכם במשחק שלא תצא מטומטם.