[MoF] Budget Analysis and Tournament Gold Surplus
Ministerie van Economische Zak
The following is a brief overview of the previous two terms budgeting and a more indepth review of our total gold surplus from the tournaments this past year and how this surplus affects our expenditures and government decisions. As always, you may check the data here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AmBBdzMqrIBmdHFrNkFfaGtSVjBrcm50YzlhYU9CU3c#gid=2
Tonie and ArcanicMindje Terms
Tonie’s term was heavily bogged down by the war with Norway and was forced to run a deficit relative to tax income which we derive our budget from. Here is the following stats:
Tax Income: 37,918
Donations: 2,200
Budget: 40,118
- - - - -
Emergency Funds: 77,880
Total Spent: 117,999
Result: -77,880
Tonie’s term ran a deficit of 77,880 of emergency funds to maintain the war. It should be noted that a large majority of the total spent, over 100k, was spent solely on Combat Orders and MPPs. In fact, when compared to the amount Norway spent just on their MPP stack at the time of the war, 10-12 MPPs, and taking into account they setup their own COs in excess over 10k, through personal observation, we spent equal to less than Norway while managing to win the war even factoring in ArcanicMindje’s term. This can be attributed to a healthy MPP and CO mix and good allied support.
ArcanicMindje’s term dealt exclusively with cleaning up the war with Norway and managed to run a surplus. Here are the stats:
Tax Income: 36,309
Budget: 36,309
- - - - -
Total Spent: 26,000
Result: 10,309
As you can see we ran roughly a 10k surplus during ArcanicMindje’s term. Although congress voted to approve a 40k MPP allowance during his term, it was never used and all of our MPPs are currently ended. It should also be noted that there were some financial issues during this term and we do not have detailed data on the exact spending. As MoD I tracked our military expenditures and recorded the basic data on the sheet as is now, but I admit it is not very transparent. I can assure you that all of the expenditures during this term were attributed to Combat Orders fighting against Norway.
Tournament Gold Surplus
This is a plan I have been meaning to work on for some time but have become distracted with other matters, such as real life. Over the past year Netherlands has been involved in three tournaments that have accumulated 8300 gold. This is an enormous surplus and when converted to NLG at the minimum transfer rate it equals 8300 x 200 = 1,660,000. Since last August we have acquired over 1.5 million NLG. Now let me break that down in terms of how much has been spent so far:
We won:
1st time: 1,400G
2nd time: 5,000G
3rd time: 1,900G
Total Earne
😛8300
Communes (Gold Reserved): 3,220 / Dave - 1,190 Heikanu - 2,030 (For 58 Raws each)
Tournament Gold Giveback (Aries): 252
- - - - -
Total Spent/Reserve
😛3,472
Result: 4,828
Now that we have figured out exactly how much gold we have spent from our winnings, let’s subtract our total deficits since August to come up with our total surplus remaining. This means that we must convert the 4,828 gold into NLG at 200 per gold. 4828 x 200 = 965,600. I admit I have trouble interpreting Weekstrom’s records since he doesn’t factor deficits or surpluses in accordance to tax income and donations and was using EF funds from previous terms in his calculations (Illegal since EF funds end after the term is finished, but debatable I’m sure), but I believe I have the right data.
Total Surplus After Gold Expenditure: 965,600
Aug: 9,464
Sept (Airstrike): 101,019
Oct: 7,394
Mar: 77,880
- - - - -
Total Deficits: 195,757
Remaining Tournament Surplus: 769,843
Now that we have taken out all deficits of the previous terms since August, we see that the total surplus winnings we have remaining are 769,843, or about 46% left.
MPP Allowance
With these remaining surplus funds of 769,843, currently still in gold form at 200 NLG per gold, I had wanted to setup a constant MPP allowance of 4-5 MPPs per term. This allowance could be used as an extension to the government budget to be used accordingly. I propose this because we are in a time where we need MPPs with our allies to show moral and actual support in battles. We are also required by our North Sea Pact to sign MPPs with our allies when the time comes. It should also be noted that this allowance would not have to be completely spent every term and all of the funding comes from tournament winnings so we are not actually dipping into our original reserves.
4 MPPs per term: 19 terms
5 MPPs per term: 15 terms
If we spent the entire allowance each term until we ran out of money, the above would be the result. I strongly suggest each citizen and congressman look into this information and formulate your own ideas of what is acceptable use of this surplus tournament winnings and how we should use them. Perhaps some of you believe we should store it all away as permanent reserves, perhaps others believe we should spend it all on MPPs, or perhaps a mixture of both. However people interpret the data, it is important to realize that Netherlands is in a very strong state financially and we do have the funds necessary to support whatever we want to pursue.
Minister of Finance
Aries Prime
State Secretary
The Valeyard
Please subscribe to the Government Newspapers
Comments
Voted
Such money
Much profit
Thanks for the report Aries! Very detailed and useful.
Thanks for your effort in this report! Very interesting!
If I did understand the commune plans correct there is no gold surplus nor do i think it was intended to transfer gold into cash as that would mean a less profitable commune.
Also the commune plan involved more players than you mention in the article so i wonder why it isn't implemented in full?
It looks like this article is mainly focussing on short term possibilities to generate money that will be wasted on a war or something in stead of long term durable benefits. I do find that sad.
You understand incorrectly. We are not following Weekstrom's plan to a T. We are using it as a foundation. You also clearly do not understand how the communes are being setup as the gold invested will make them self-sustainable. That is the primary goal.
As for more players in the commune plan, that is incorrect. We only have two players for communes right now. If we need to add a third, then we will, but so far we this isn't an objective.
MoF should not have anything to do with setting up communes aside from providing the bankroll.
MoF is not MoD.
i understand perfectly well Aries. I fear it's you who didn't comprehend the plan of weekstrom then. Even if you're not following it, which is a big loss imo, i wonder which part you don't follow although I estimate you will only persue standard commune work in stead of the valuable extra's that had a vision on how to grow strong as a nation.
But even if you miss all those extra's; We should still persue maxed out communes so our stronger players that have teir training maxed out receive 12-18 weps which was weekstrom's goal.
And indeed garmr; Communes is no issue for MoF. But if i read/heard correct Weekstrom did come up with the plan as MoD didn't act on it for 1½ years or so and only did destructive work on our forces letting PG grow in the process. The latter seems to be changed luckily. So now lets make the commune strong. Including registration that was also part of the masterplan on communes of Weekstrom.
As stated before; we now seem to miss the opportunity to do so especially as Aries stated he wants to sell gold for cash and that can only be short term focused. Investing the gold will give us long term prosperity which should have priority....
So you want Dave's commune at only 34 raws?
He started with 24 if the information he has told me is accurate.
So he is donating them?
*sigh* speak to me on IRC or pm if you want full details.
What is that all about? Last time I checked Dave only has private raws. And that extra info you can share is clearly something that should be added here. (or in the forums of course)
He is letting us use his raws in conjunction with the ones we are purchasing. Again, I'm happy to answer questions, but I'm not going to do a blow by blow in the article itself.
Yeah well that because he is so great at providing numbers and keeping track right. It goes both ways if you want to get oversight.
hard voted
What a completely messed up sheet you're pointing to. I sure hope because that's only because its a temp public sheet as otherwise it is an idiotic action to make our financial overview public knowledge...
As for the article itself; Why would we transfer gold into cc only to sign MPP's we can not afford from our standard budget? That's very narrow vissioned. I don't know the details of the commune plan of Weekstrom that is referred to but if that implies investing the gold into long term growth and strength opposed to short term playing money it should always prevail.
I hate that sheet too... 😉
That implies it's our official sheet... Very sad someone felt the need to make it public. That's very strange I'd say. Not a real surprise given the idea to transfer gold into MPP's though 🙁
4-5 MPPs are typically not needed. Signing MPPs with allies who need our help, or with all allies if we need help should never be a problem, also not if it needs to go through congress (quickened emergency procedure).
But there are better ways to systematically spend money than on MPPs which won't have any effect. Joint strikes with free supplies are an example, training subsidies, even if only to get the first training ground to Q2 asap, and as a loan system (which has to be repayed without interest). And indeed the communes which people already mentioned. These consistently take up money (even if the commune owners also subsidise them themselves).
great article, some insight in whats going on with our winnings.
o7